Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai 13th May 2023 Written Episode, Written Update on TellyUpdates.com
The Episode starts with Surekha asking Abhinav buy a bike for Abhir or take him on any world trip, can he support his education or treatment, no, he can’t, but Abhi can, Manish will say money isn’t everything, love and values also matter, but this won’t matter in court, sorry Abhinav can’t become capable like Abhi. They see Muskaan behind. Akshu hears Abhinav and cries. Muskaan says Abhinav is the most capable and rich, everyone comes empty handed in the world, he had no one with him, he has learnt love and family by joining relations, Neela and I used to live in neighborhood, he joined relations with us, today, he has a Dadi, sister, wife and son, he is very rich. Akshu goes to Abhinav. He asks why can’t I earn, a person can make a stone melt, I have to do this, I m a good father, I will earn money for my Abhir. Akshu smiles and keeps the keys there. She goes. Abhi says idea is good. Manjiri says I will meet an architect and make Abhir’s room next to your room. Abhi recalls Akshu and Abhinav’s words. He says I was thinking we won’t do this now, if the case goes in court, we will wait. She says we will win the case at any cost, my grandson will stay here, Abhir is your son, not a guest, just think of you.
Ruhi asks will Abhi come to stay in our house. Abhi sees Ruhi and Aarohi. Akshu calls Mathur and clears her doubt. He says you are in right state of mind. Akshu says yes, I get panic and anxiety attacks sometimes, I thought to tell you, I m ready for psychic evaluation, Birlas can use this against us. He says everyone is scared to discuss mental health issues, but you have told me about this, don’t worry, we will be prepared. She sees Abhinav looking at her and greets morning. He says I used to see you studying every day, you used to be lost in books and I used to be lost in you. She says you like to see me studying. He says you look good even when you scold, small house, small life, it was ours, when will we go back to Kasauli. She says we can’t go there, but Kasauli can come here. Ruhi asks why will Abhir stay here, why did you call him, he has two houses. Abhi says your brother will stay with you. She argues. Akshu and Muskaan bring Abhir and Abhinav downstairs. Abhir and Abhinav say we have a fragrance of Kasauli. Akshu shows Neela to them. Abhinav hugs Neela. Surekha thinks everyone is coming here to stay. Abhi says this is your house. Aarohi scolds Ruhi and takes her. Abhi worries. Manish gives a gift to Neela. He says we didn’t know you are coming, else we would have planned a good welcome. Neela thanks them and gets emotional. Dadi asks her to sit. Suwarna washes Neela’s feet.
She says you are our Samdhan, you have given values to Muskaan and Abhir, you will always be special for us. Neela cries. Manish says bahu welcomes her Saas by singing a song. Neela says Akshu sings also, I never heard her singing. Manish asks Akshu to sing. Akshu plays guitar and sings life is beautiful. Neela smiles. Everyone claps. Kairav says Neela looks cute, but she has slapped me by her eyes. Muskaan says she will slap by hands also this time. He says see, how she is looking at her. She laughs and jokes. He says I m not scared of her, I have to talk to her about the alliance.
Neela says you sing so well, I never heard it. Abhir says mum used to sing just for dad. Akshu says shut up. They smile. Neela gifts them the things and says what can I give you all, I got these Himachal things. Surekha says we don’t use shawl and cap here, thanks. Akshu taunts Surekha. Manish says show the room to Neela. Abhinav lies in Neela’s lap and says you have come, I needed you a lot. She says I should have come before, I came when Akshu called me. He gets a message. He says I got the first booking, I have to go. She blesses him. He looks for the key. Akshu says its here, how did you like the key ring, we are always with you, this is the key to happinss. Abhinav says it’s the best, I will never stop when I see this. Akshu says all the best. Abhinav drives to Birla house. Nishta says sorry, I don’t have cash, my phone got off. She goes. Abhinav sees her face when she removes the veil. He says its Nishta, I can’t take money from her. He sees the key ring. Nishta says my phone got off, do you have cash, I have to give 500rs to cab driver. Abhi goes to Abhinav. He gives the money. Abhinav asks him to give one rupee shagun for his son. Abhi asks him to take it. Abhinav says I will take it with respect. Abhi says I will pray you become a big man and get every wish fulfilled, except one, your wish to make my son away from me doesn’t get fulfilled. Abhi says I know basic calculations, don’t keep the ordinary and don’t leave the precious thing. He gives the money back and just keeps the coin.
Precap:
Abhir says I will wear my new shoes. Akshu scolds Abhi for gifting expensive shoes to Abhir. Aarohi says Ruhi doesn’t like you spending time with her poppy. Abhir says I have to go home right away, please drop me home. Abhi worries.
Update Credit to: Amena
89 Comments
Samdhan ke pair kaun dhota hai 😂😂😂
Abhinav is already facing financial crisis upar se rs 500 vapas kar diye jo uske mehnat ke the..sorry but aisa fizool ka mahanta koi kaam ka naii infact its stupidity.. But as makers are hell bent on showing abhinav as some bhagwan + kal fir use bechara dikhayenge.. Ek din bhagwaan agle din bechara.. Nd his arrogant wife will again fight with abhimanyu for no reason..whats wrong if he gifted expensive shoes to his son.. Aj kal har dusra bacchha expensive footwear pehenta hai infact middle class parents v expensive gifts dete hai aj kal.. So whats wrong if he gifted? Did he ask abhir to throw old shoes in dustbin? I dont think so..why this mindset that expensive gifts dene se bacchha zada demanding ho jayga? Humesha aisa nai hota..He can easily afford so of course he will give ufff akshu has a problem with everything.. For her, if roohi behaves like a beat, manyu is responsible.. If lawyer mocks her husband’s financial suitation, manyu is responsible.. If abhir behaves like brat, manyu is responsible.. He is responsible for everything on earth
@Surabhi ..whatever you said is absolutely correct and Abhinav’s character is like this only …see back when he was in Kasauli there were more than 40 passengers who didn’t paid him..there was also a list ..No change in character behaviour …no one has changed despite of the situations..
Bin baat pe gifts milna from a relative is very sus.
Abhir’s Birthday just passed, he already gifted him many and now again a new gift so soon.
Manjiri is building a room and Abhimanyu is buying stuffs which fascinates Abhir for what?
To make him happy and so that Abhir will love him more. That’s the only logical reason when someone gifts so often.
@surabhi. You are saying like if abhinav doesn’t take that money he will never be rich and it is like only with that money he will be able to be rich. No its not. Its not stupidity or mahan nature that was going to highlight but the love for a kid he raised for the past yrs. Just like Abhi abhinav also loves abhir and just like abhi for abhinav abhir is his world. Abhinav doesn’t value anything more than abhir. Why he returned money and kept tge coin bcz abhi wished to fulfill all his dreams except about abhir. But abhinav replied to abhis wish that he values abhir more than abhinavs likes and dislikes. It is love towards a kid between two fathers, one who missed his kid for yrs and the other who raised a kid for many yrs. Abhinav rejected money from abhi for a reason and thag doesn’t mean that he is stupid or mahan to reject all the money he get from his work. Like abhi abhinav also loves abhir a lot and what’s wrong with that.
@🙂 ur right! The token of money has different meaning as in this case, Abhinav knows what he is doing! Before he was not in financial problem they were living well n happy, he still can afforded to not take money from passengers as he felt he still can managed!
i think you are rich enough, so you can’t understand love, affection, bringing up, sanskar self respect etc. jarurath se jaada denese bache bigad jaate hai. obhi chote umarse.
Sorry to say but ur logic is just so stupid. Imaging living with a child for 6yrs and all or a sudden that child is gone . Although I won’t deny the fact also that abhinav shld have collected his cab money from abhimanyu
Cant sympathize with arohi anymore.. Cant she take roohi and shift to goenkas if she has so much problem? Why trying to separate abhimanyu and abhir that too peet piche? In dono behno ko sab kuc peet piche hi karna hota hai in the name of parivar ki khushi
She is helping Akshara, Abhinav and indirectly Abhimanyu too.
Future episodes mai aisa track zarur ayega jab Abhimanyu Abhir ko Akshara se alag karega aur Akshara ko Phirse Get lost bol dega.
Also
When it comes to Abhinav’s responsibility, he doesn’t listens to Akshu also. He does what he feels right. Also he only encouraged Akshara to Stop her Jam business and focus on studies.
This is called Assertion for good.
He doesn’t expect any from Akshara. That’s why he doesn’t confront.
In near future he will be Assertive. Those situations are yet to come. How you forget that Abhinav wanted Abhir to get treatment done in Udaipur by Abhimanyu while Akshara was totally against it. They argued 2-3 episodes.
Good thing is that they didn’t acted toxic.
Still if he looks Puppet then i hope you also agree that Abhimanyu is A Puppet Son.
Nd y akshu’s mentality is sooo poor? How can she think that he is trying to get abhir by giving him luxuries? Gift ke liye itna bawaal.. She will not leave any stone unturned to guilt trip him as he still loves her
After seeing what Abhi did to Kairav yesterday after he was given the go ahead to take Abhir, i will not be suprised if this was his motives i.e.to buy Abhirs love. Anyways, lets wait for tomorrow for us to judge.
@Mark I agree he was like “see Kairav?” But so unnecessary! Kairav reaction was cute
Abhi give gifts to his son by his earned money for sometime I hated abhi but this akshu is worst if kairav r Manish gifted expensive at that time also she would have scolded them akshu can’t give expensive gifts so she blaming abhi I think now that abhi whatever did during neil death was correct sorry guys but this akshu responsible for own destruction she is more attention seeker than aarohi if she returned to goenka house arohi would have got more attention bcoz she lost neil so only she did not return and naira akshu they can easily abandon maayka for their husband mistakes I don’t give damn about goenka but due to naira her parents can’t be in peace for 7 years when she run away as teen akshu u fool if u return to goenka this mess would not happened
What happens to Abhir tomorrow will convince you otherwise.
Akshu staying away was more harmless than harmfull. Because if Arohi did not be entangled with Abhi now, Abhir transition to Birla family tree, would have happened smoothly.
For bhagwan abhinav shagun ka 1 rupya imp hai but hard earned 500 rupees is not imp.. Khud ka naya hua paisa luta do nd thn go to self victimization mode 😑
@niruban exactly.. She made goenkas suffer for what? Trusted a stranger thn married him thn made him his bacchha ka baap coz real baap ne phn nai uthaya😏 i mean ye aurat kuc v karti hai.. Sara raaita faila ke bhaag gayi thi or ab sabse badi victim hai ye
@surabhi disagreed with your this point woh bhag e nahi thi …usey nikala Gaya tha ….and regarding Abhinav he considers even Birla his family ..so his mindset is family se paise nahi liye jatey …
@Shilajit
No one threw her away out of Goenka house, she herself walked away and sent one emotional voice note that she’s going far away, like it was in her to send a voice note to her family but couldn’t do it when she had to inform Abhimanyu about one child being alive and changed father because he didn’t lift that call🤡
And even if Abhi wants to buy gifts for Abhir what’s the problem…in there sometimes this Akshu Is so impulsive…you see maybe that’s why she and Abhimanyu didn’t work …because both were same of the kind …
Abhimanyu just found out that he has a son. He will buy expensive gifts for his son. Arohi should leave Birla mansion with her daughter. She is always trying to manipulate people. What rubbish she telling Abir that Ruhi don’t want him to live at Birla mansion. Abir is a Birla. He has more rights to Abhimanyu than Ruhi. Arohi should be honest with both children. Ruhi doesn’t know that Abhimanyu her poppy, is Abir ‘s dad. Arohi needs to find Ruhi a new poppy. Abhinav would be a good poppy for Ruhi. He would teach her some manners and how to behave properly. Kairav should stop being so aggressive. Keep out of Akshu’s life. Abir also need to know that Abhi is his real father.
Lets assume a cab driver in Udaipur can earn 60lakhs per month on average without putting considerations on setbacks. This means Nav confidence is justified. Which means, these setbacks can be tackled by Goenkas as their support for Jamaisa which is equivalent to Birlas support to Manyu. Since makers removed Akshu from financial contribution, this becomes a battle between Manyu and Nav. I am definately feeling some competition vibes.
Nav is starting out but Manyu is way ahead. Tomorrow, Abhir will get shoes from Manyu, but Nav is not yet in a position to shower Abhir with material things. I hope Akshu will level the playing field and ask Manyu to pause the material competition for two months.
NB: this financial plan of Nav that requires 60 lakhs earnings per month can help their case in terms of financial capabilities between Nav and Manyu.
Akshu: clearly Akshu is still a novice in law. Her anxiety and panick attacks can be used in court but the fact that she is aware of them and her family is aware of them and is currently receiving treatment for them, puts her in a good position.
NB: if makers consult a law proffesional on the state of this custody case and decide to show the case in real sense, then Manyu and Akshu will have equal chances at Abhir. This means the judge will go with shared custody. But i am sure makers have no time to do law research and hence, along the way, someone will bail the whole court issue and agree for out of court settlement.
Arohi: she is being strict to Ruhi but for wrong explanations or reasons. She shouted at Ruhi just because no one will answer Ruhi? Isnt that what is bothering Ruhi too? She is asking questions but no one is explaining anything. Arohi should explain to Ruhi that Manyu loves Abhir too as he loves you. Her explanations should be void of hatred, selfishness, insecurity and possession. But looking at precap, i can see instead of explaining to Ruhi that Abhir wants to spend time with you and Manyu, she is telling Abhir to f**k off by justifying Ruhi. Its clear now. Whatever Arohi wants for Ruhi can never be possible. Abhir is Manyu son. There is no way Abhi will choose Ruhi over his son. And that is fine. All is left for Arohi is cooperate and support Manyu in making Ruhi and Abhir friends.
But i wonder one thing. If Abhir was Abhis son by another woman who is not Akshu, will Arohi still push Abhir? Is Arohi reluctant to accept Abhir as Manyu son just because Ruhi is throwing a tantrum or there is other hidden agendas??????🤔
From the precap, i can see all efforts of Manyu will be rendered useless if Arohi doesnt see that Ruhis demands are silly and should not be encouraged.
@Mark
Why should Aarohi explain to Ruhi that her poppy loves her the same as he loves Abhir and give her false hopes and keep her in delusions when clearly Abhimanyu’s behavior is opposite. It can be clearly seen in summer camp how he forgot Ruhi’s existence. Ruhi is feeling change from her poppy, not from her Matashree, she’s still important for her Matashree same as before but her importance and priority in poppy’s life is shaken up, so obviously poppy will have to give her explanations, but he will be able to explain when he himself understands what’s actually wrong with Ruhi, Aarohi, Akshara, even 6 year old Abhir understood what’s bothering Ruhi, but this 40 year man who claims himself as Ruhi’s father couldn’t understand, he just stuck to her and used her as trauma and pain escape but never was really a parent to her, if he was, he would have understood what is bothering Ruhi, she even openly expressed even then nothing went inside his head, once Abhir dumps him, he’ll again stick to her saying princess princess and if Abhir comes back again, he’ll leave Ruhi and stick to Abhir. If Abhimanyu is not able to choose Ruhi, he should have courage to say it directly to her that he can’t be her papa anymore and that Abhir is also equally important to him, but he’s still giving her hopes and calling her beti, he kept on saying, Abhir is your bhai, like bro, she knows Abhir is her bahi, but she wants to know why suddenly her bhai became soo important to her poppy when he is someone else kid. Aarohi have no problem with the fact that Abhir’s mother is Akshara, she’s feeling insecue that her daughter will be left alone like her and she already saw the demo of it in camp, if Abhimanyu atleast spared a glance to Ruhi when she was hurt, she wouldn’t be this insecure. Abhimanyu gave all sorts of promises to both Ruhi and Aarohi, gave hopes to Ruhi, his mother and bhabhi emotionally manipulated Aarohi when she cancelled engagement and even he went to her with trust, respect speech and the mother-son duo threw them away as soon as they got their khoon, especially his mother.
Ruhi’s demands are not silly, infact she’s not even demanding anything right now, she’s questioning her poppy regarding his change for which he has no answer, all ever did was jumping in when Aarohi tried to school Ruhi and overly pampered and now the same kid is suffering.
@..
You are right but you leave me questioning myself.
1. Is it possible the change Ruhi is feeling is Abhis love is divided into two equal parts or the parts are not equal?
2.is there no way Arohi can answer Ruhis questions regardless of who they are directed to? Cant she be bold and say anything that gives closure to Ruhi? Must she shout at Ruhi for expecting answers that she will never get or she should even say the truth that since Abhir is Manyu son that is why his love is not all yours anymore?
3. Arohi was left alone by who?
@..
Totally agree.. And till now we were not shown Manjiri talking with Arohi on this matter. She is speechless since she knows what she did and doing is wrong. After giving so many hopes now Manjiri is aksing Arohi indirectly to backoff. And yes Abhi has not yet realised what Roohi’s question is still he gives hopes and nxt minute make her shatter. When Arohi tries to take Roohi out of this mess Abhi won’t let it happen either. So for Arohi she thinks the only way is not letting Abhir come between poppy and Roohi. Arohi could have explain to roohi but we have seen that roohi is more attached to poppy and she doesn’t listen what Arohi says. She needs an answer from the person who has changed only. But he has unable to understand the issue what he does is when he sees Roohi is going away from him just look at his hand and grab Roohi but again forgets her.
@
Exactly, Manjiri qas the one who pushed Aarohi towards marriage for her convenience and now wants her to back out herself for her own convenience, what type of women is she. And yesterday, I felt like she wants to make Aarohi step mom of her own nephew by snatching Abhir from Akshara, she has completely lost it. Not only Manjiri Abhimanyu also gave hopes, now both mother-son flipped and forgot Ruhi. I don’t think they’ll let Aarohi and Ruhi leave the house too, as for Manjiri I’m feeling like she’s keeping them as backup now, if Abhir rejects them, they can have Ruhi🙄
Abhimanyu shod really stop seeing his hand every now and then, seeing hand 20 times a day doesn’t solve the issue nor will show him as best parent. He’s looking funny each time he did that
Wow mahan sharma ,bechari akshu n arohi and the biggest demon abhi ki story where the fault of demon is he loves bechari akshu endlessly.the goenka karirav cld not save his sister from demon it cld lead others sis to sucid wow n mahan gorilla families kya baat,but but we the audience r soo great giving them the required trp n more
first this story belongs to akshu and aarohi not toxicmanyu.
@Ritu
You said it all, it was first Akshara Singhania’s story, next her daughter Naira’s story, noe her grand daughter’s story, people qatch for their story not that flipmanyu, Abhimanyu character got hype just because of Harshad’s huge fan base that doesn’t mean people are watching for his story. Aarohi is an important part as she’s also Kartik’s daughter. They should have focused on these 2 sisters from beginning instead of some cringe romance
@Shilajit
Exactly abhi throw her out k I understand but y the hell she did not take help from goenkas to develop in her career if she stayed poor it is her choice but how can she raise abhir in poor environment during phone call abhi speak harshly k I understand if kairav died bcoz of abhi at that time also akshu remain silent abhi whatever did at that time was not due to anger but due to loss of neil i want abhi to snatch abhir custody akshu is mad at abhi lot now a days she did not show her anger to manjiri and arohi but she is guilttripping him like aaru did that to akshu for sirat death I know abhinav is good man but no matter how much good person can be no great man will allow his kid to call another man papa so abhi anger is justified if abhir call any other mom can she tolerate that how dare she ask abhi to giveup abhir for ruhi like she did for aarohi abhi is looking up ruhi for neil and also her mistakes only she did not even recognise her mistakes
Again same jaap.
Why Akshara did this…that…
Abhimanyu met his son after 6 years and I understand his emotions, he wants to balance between kids and wants to be papa of both, this is something which is not possible, he said that he and Neil dreamt that their kids should be raised together, but now situations are not same anymore. Abhimanyu and Neil shared same parents, here both kids have different mothers, Neil is no more, one mom is married to another man who is foster father and step father of his son who knows him as his real father and is too attached to him, then there is another kid who knows her father is no more and grew up seeing Abhimanyu as father, if he wants to be papa of both the kids, he’ll forever have to juggle between 2 homes and 2 cities as Sharmas may go back to Kasauli. He should better stop giving false hopes to Ruhi and just tell that he can’t become her papa anymore, her heart will break anyhow, so breaking it with bitter truth is better than giving hopes till end and keeping the kid in confusion. He was the one who made her believe in “No Sharing” and made her center of his world and out of the blue can’t expect her to accept another kid in her poppy’s life that too who’s just a cousin for her. The funny thing is he is not even understanding what is troubling Ruhi and is going on chanting “Tunhara bhai”, even 6 year old Abhir understood Ruhi is feeling insecure but this 40 year old man is not able to understand. In summer camp episodes he clearly ignored Ruhi for someone else child according to her. He didn’t check in which team she’s going, didn’t spare a glance when Akshara mentioned she got scratch, didn’t bother to cheer her up when she lost. He’s the same man who used to run to Ruhi even when she faked illness. He and his mother are lost cases to think Abhir will leave his mom and Abhinav with whom he was there since his birth and grew up for them. I’m not getting with what face Manjiri is planning a room for Abhir, she’s too over-confident. Befor knowing Abhir’s truth, Ruhi and Aarohi are daughters for Manjiri, but now Aarohi is a means to show court that her son have perfect family and can give both parents love to Abhir, I’m sure she’s planning to make Aarohi step mother of her own nephew, she should have some sense before even trying to think about that. And Ruhi is invisible for her now, today that kid was crying and seeking answers, atleast Abhimanyu is trying to console her, but this so called mother of Aarohi and Ruhi didn’t even flinch or show an expression of concern when Ruhi is crying. Aarohi should have neevr let this mother-son duo become soo close to Ruhi, they used her as trauma escape and now forgot her when they got their own so called khoon, as if Ruhi was not their khoon.
Akshara is behaving little sane now, many people are bashing her for thinking to take therapy beforehand regarding her panic attacks so that Abhimanyu’s lawyer don’t point that out, but I didn’t find any wrong in that, it is as practical approach as Abhimanyu’s lawyer pointing out Sharma family financial status. The preparations and calculations which Abhinav-Akshara are doing now, they should have done in these 6 years only be it planning finances or preparing case file for custody, Akshara kept on saying I was prepared for this day whenever she got a chance, so I’m wondering what she actually prepared because I can’t see any preparation form their side.
Akshara ne aise kyun kiya …woh Goenkas ki help kyu nahi li ? Pehli baat jab Kairav aur Akshara gayeb hue thei us waqt bhi dono ne koi financial help nahi liya tha Goenkas se …so tab kyun leti woh …aur woh bhi un Goenkas se Jo Akshara ko blame karte thei for Neil’s death …aur jisne Abhimanyu se ek sawal bhi nahi puhncha ki kyu usne Akshara ko aise akele halat mein chale Jane ko kaha jab usne miscarriage Kiya tha …unse woh paise mangti ..she chose to stay “poor ” …no Poverty usey tab Tak hit nahi Kiya tha jab Tak Abhir ki surgery ki baat nahi hua …tab Tak un logon ko paise ki dikyat thi lekin woh log manage karte thei acche se …aur ha Abhimanyu ka anger justified hain …ki woh nahi dekh sakta koi aur ko uska beta papa bulai … Abhimanyu ko khud hi realise hoga ki Abhir ke liye best kya hain …kyunki Birla House aur Goenka house sirf” kids with issues ” raise kar sakte hain …
@Shilajit
How are anyone wrong in blaming Akshara for Neil’s death, everyone except her knows that Neil dies due to her foolish decisions, but she won’t accept because she did all those with “good intentions”, do hell with her good intentions, when the end result of her actions are always soo bad, who wants to see if her intentions are good or bad, Goenkas should have blasted on her when she disappeared for an year just like how Singhanias blasted on Naira when she faked death, Goenkas always hailed her stupidity because of which she don’t know how to do things in right way, she just sees her intentions. Medical emergencies don’t come giving a message before an year, they come suddenly only, as Abhir’s parents they should have been prepared for this, every middle class family parents do medical insurance, they do some investments just to save money for emergency medical expenses but they didn’t do that. She preaches about her non-existent law degree as she didn’t write exam till now, so doesn’t she know that all these are normal in custody case, why to over react soo much, yesterday she said “I want to play fair”, but it’s looking like she’s paying safe because she know that her side is weak in case.
@.. Totally agree.
she choose to stay poor if she really studied law she could have guessed her financial situation is questioned and i dont believe akshu abhinav is endgame bcoz makers will not allow that only abhira is endgame it would been akshu remained single rich parent if she focused on singing may be this day would not have come she had nice voice and singing talent one could have excel in whatever they r best at and do u all believe that abhira is not endgame
I hate the idea of teaching a child to be selfish coz in the end.thats part of what makes them toxic as adults…I like when abhir said not ‘snatching but sharing” to arohi…Aarohi shuld teach roohi same….that will make rooohi to stop having temper tantrums
Surekha is right despite his bad intentions, Abhinav has to prove that he earns a regular, monthly and sufficient fixed income to support Abhir, taxi driver does not provide a fixed monthly salary. Abhinav’s choice not to take help and too naive despite Akshara and Muskaan’s big talk. Just to underline Abhinav’s good side he was made too naive, Akshara’s goodwill was toxic, I feel like Abhinav is going to become like Akshara of the past. Abhimanyu practically raised Niel and considered him as his son and Niel said many times that Abhimanyu was like a father to him, but Abhimanyu always pampered Niel and fulfilled all his material desires Abhimanyu’s overflowing love didn’t make Niel bad though, so why is Akshara always saying that Abhimanyu is not qualified to be a good father, when she knows that it was almost Abhimanyu who raised Niel? . the only variable in Birla house is Arohi, and Manjiri’s new toxic behavior, if Arohi and Manjiri were more balanced, Ruhi would never have turned the wrong way. At the time of Niel Abhimanyu and Manjiri was like the parents of Niel and Manjiri was not yet toxic they knew how to balance the education and the evolution of Niel between the overflowing love of Abhimanyu and the maternal side of Manjiri. Abhimanyu works and earns money if not for the benefit of his family, then why should he work? Should he deprive himself because Akshara cannot give Abhir what he can give and should he always feel bad for Abhinav every time he wants to give Abhir a gift. Abhimanyu feels guilt for the Sharmas and he shouldn’t, as Akshara has no intention of sympathizing with him.
@yeol
I have to ask. If Neil was such a good boy, what was he thinking when he fought with Manyu his brother????
Neil thought its true that he is below Abhi and Abhi treats him as such. If he was such a good boy from Abhis love and upbringing, what went wrong?
@Mark when it’s singing to you you said Niel was a good boy, you even said he had the same values as your Akshu but when it doesn’t suit you then you forget your own speech? The person who had sparked this argument you knew who it was, the person who influenced him you know who it was , but you forgot that he had asked Abhimanyu for forgiveness and that he had quickly recognized his errors. Abhimanyu and Niel never had an argument before the involvement of the two sisters and even after the revelation for his father he ended up asking Abhimanyu for forgiveness for having spoken to him badly but to discredit Abhimanyu you will forget all the facts and even accused Niel that you rented
@Mark, you know very well that Niel was a good person, and before Arohi’s manipulations and intrigues, he had never done anything wrong, and he had always supported this unconscious Akshara, but for Akshara you are even willing to smear Niel’s memory, just to find mistakes in Abhimanyu’s upbringing way.
🤔
Neil was naive like Akshu and always acted if he sees something wrong is happening. But after revelation that he is not an orphan, he was the only one that looked after Harsh despite what harsh did to him. Then Arohi started imposing her jealousy and insecurity on him. My concern is that these manipulations worked. And i support Neils claims though i dont support his method of getting his point across. So if Manyu was so good, he would have treated Neil as a heir and not a child. And Neil would have used another way of communicating his troubles that didnt involve fighting with everyone.(like father,Abhi like son,Neil)
Anyways, i never blamed Neil for his actions since i never saw the relevance but in this comment of yours i saw the relevance.
I actually agreed with all you said except the part of Nav being too naive to think cab driver will generate enough income to fulfill Abhir basic needs and material needs. In real life and in some countries, that is not the case. But according to yrkkh, Nav calculated Abhir needs per month and saw that him alone and his cab driving job, if he works with determination, he will reach his goal.
Also what i strongly questioned, is “Abhi is a good father” statement of yours. Since Abhir is a boy i used Neil as an example. Anger issues can be transfered from father to son as i elaborated earlier. But if i am to ignore gender, then the fact that Manyu doesnt know what is bothering Ruhi is the deal breaker.
In your comment, Akshara is not relevant. So how did you find my comment biased?
@Mark Abhimanyu it’s now that the closeness he has with Abhir bothers Ruhi but he doesn’t understand his insecurities as he firmly believes he can love them both and will bring them equal importance. He has always pampered Ruhi so he is baffled that she might think that Abhir is more important than her in her life, he is so caught up in his new relationship with Abhir wanting to bond and fight for his custody, that Abhimanyu doesn’t doesn’t realize that he is getting neglectful towards Ruhi because for him his feelings for Ruhi don’t change, so he doesn’t see why it would be awkward to spend time with Abhir
. Abhimanyu tried to include Ruhi in his moments with Abhir but Ruhi is reluctant he even asked Ruhi to call him brother. Manjiri is so hypocritical that she herself does an injustice to Arohi, she plunged Arohi into marriage, but in her enthusiasm for Abhir she only focuses on him and forgets Arohi and Ruhi. For Abhimanyu Abhir and new in his life, he tries to get acquainted with Abhir and familiarize Abhir to be with him, he doesn’t understand this is more than jealousy for Ruhi but possessiveness, and as you told regarding Abhimanyu if no one tells him clearly, Abhimanyu will not understand where he is wrong, and it is the role of the family to explain to Ruhi and Abhimanyu their mistakes. And for Abhinav for their old way of living his income was enough but now he has to prove that every month he can reach the same amount and taxi driver and inconstant job where the income is not stable because the number of customers all vary days. That’s why I think it’s naive maybe there would be a fanciful twist to justify his choice but compared to Birla who can do well above financially the court will favor Birla’s financial situation . it is the Sharma family status that is important because being married is important in the eyes of the judge, but Birla knows from Akshara their real relationship and there were witnesses who heard everything.
SINCE WHEN WAS AKSHARA UNCONSCIOUS?????¿¿
@Yeol, again you have said much of what I would have. Surekha is the only one taking sense in the Goenkas house. And exactly my sentiment that Abhimanyu should stop over sympathising with the Sharmas because this new, tougher, rougher Akshara would have no qualms about stabbing him left right and centre to achieve her ends.
And what is wrong with that?? U dun stop defending when someone is bashing u would u?????
@yeol
Surekha is the only one who’s speaking sense right now, even if her intention is to just stir up the situation. I felt like laughing when Muskaan came and gave a long lecture about how her brother earned relations, family, etc. like dude, court don’t see all these things. Yes, Abhinav is a very good person but court runs on facts, not on emotions.
Abhimanyu loved Neil like his own son, but he could never really protect Neil from his father’s taunts and abuse, same goes with Manjiri, she gave all motherly love to Neil but couldn’t save him from her husband’s taunts. In Neil’s case, he was more like indebted to Abhimanyu and Manjiri for giving him a family and loving him and silently stood as their support system in all the things they did, but that’s not the case with Ruhi, she’s that house daughter who got undivided attention from her dida and poppy but now someone else child, according to her is getting more preference than her by her own family and she wants answers for it. Not getting the answers is making her more confused and shattered.
@.., I didn’t feel their relationship like that because Abhimanyu has always fought back in front of Harsh to protect Niel and always said that whatever Harsh says Niel will always be his brother. But yes he couldn’t completely protect him because he worked together and lived in the same house there were always times when Niel met Harsh face to face and Harsh took advantage of it to put him down, it was Manjiri’s mistake she was so afraid of Harsh that she exposed her two sons to Harsh’s behavior, if she had divorced earlier things would have been different for Niel and Abhimanyu. Niel and Abhimanyu had a real brotherly bond and Niel loved Abhimanyu so much that he kept saying that he was like a father to him, and despite Manjiri’s lie he ended up understanding his decision and forgiving her completely because she was his mother in his heart. There was a lot of gratitude in his love but they really loved them.
@..compared to the other older members of Goenka, Surekha is really smart and looks at the situation realistically, but she likes to create trouble too much, she likes to observe other people’s despair too much.
@rachna coz we are not blind bhakts of anyone.. Abhimanyu is paying for his mistakes(lost akshu, abhir) but akshu is getting rewarded for her mistakes (got abhinav, abhir) and still shown as victim.. Just like in anupamaa both anu and anuj were at fault but dkp as usual showing like all fault is of anuj and showing anu’s solo journey nd all
Sooo true.. What if abhir dies during operation due to ABHIMANYU’S STUPIDITY OR CARELESSNESS? wont akshu blast at him? Abhimanyu lost his bro, his unborn kid, also on the verge of losing his mom.. Still akshu was like “maine kya kiya, meri kya galti”huh pagal aurat
@Surabhi
Leave Abhir, that day instead of Akshara and Neil, if it was Abhimanyu and Kairav and Kairav lost his life, would she spare Abhimanyu, absolutely no. Then she’ll start her so called lectures about how Abhimanyu is careless, irresponsible blah blah, but when she’s the cause, she plays victim, she always does that, first does some kaand, then cry infront of everyone to get everyone on her side and play victim, never once she accepted her fault from the time Gen 3 started. People compare her to Aarohi saying Aarohi did worst things, yes, she did, but outcome was never soo disastrous and most important thing is Aarohi is a grey character, so she’s exactly behaving how grey character should behave, but Akshara being FL is looking more like a vamp now. Abhimanyu is no less, he always looked like a villan more than hero, but now Akshara became irritating and annoying. Can’t believe she’s the same Akshara I loved to the core in initial days.
@.. Akshara never tried to put himself in other people’s shoes. she made choices but always ended up victimizing herself if her choices went wrong. She makes long speeches to make others feel guilty and Goenka will congratulate her and give her the impression that she has done well. Arohi is not really gray, she doesn’t really have a good nature because just for her own interests she does not hesitate to manipulate and plot now she even turns the mind of a young child. Ruhi loves Abhir even though she is jealous, as Ruhi’s mother, she has a responsibility to teach good value to Ruhi and not expect anything from people if she finds Ruhi is wrong and she knows the reason, Arohi should take the initiative to correct her herself instead of leaving her in her mistake. She will just mess up the relationship between Abhir and Ruhi, because she has expectations on Abhimanyu, not correcting Ruhi will make her even more demanding of Abhimanyu and comfort her that her way of doing and speaking is not wrong.
(it’s my point of view) but women are often more involved in the education of children than some fathers who spend their time pampered playing and giving material needs to the child. And this is the case of Arohi she has a better understanding of Ruhi than Abhimanyu but she does nothing to reassure or explain to her daughter.
@yeol
Exactly, she never even empathized with Birlas when they faced 2 deaths, instead wanted everyone to roam around her and pamper her that time also, and then plays victim if people didn’t pamper her. Goenkas really failed in their upbringing that their daughters turned out so. At this point, Aarohi is clearly understanding what the actual problem is, but she is not getting how to solve it, as I said earlier, she herself is a messed up person since childhood, till everything is fine, she managed Ruhi really well but now that problem occurred in her daughter’s paradise, she isn’t understanding how to solve it without hurting anyone. And people around her also are really not cooperating with her, she can’t even assure Ruhi that everything is fine and give her false hopes because clearly Ruhi can see nothing is same like before, and it will never be, in summer camp episodes, Ruhi told Akshara that she misses her poppy WHO used to play with her and be with her everytime, and now she lost that poppy, she can never get him back. Hopefully, maybe Aarohi will take the right decision very soon before Ruhi starts to face abandonment
issues as she atleast understood what Ruhi is feeling unlike her so called poppy who isn’t even understanding what’s bothering Ruhi in 1st place. What broke my heart today is she’s feeling that her poppy is not paying attention to her anymore because she’s not sufficient enough for him, to play with him and she’s blaming everything on herself, I felt for her when she said, “I’ll play everything with you”.
@.., you gave me another perspective of Ruhi’s feelings, indeed this whole situation must have upset her.
@shailjit when akhsu kairav disappeared tab obviously dr khera unka expense uthaye honge as he only took them at his place.. But during pregnancy she knows she is not alone but has her baby’s responsibility still instead of going to her home khud bhi garibi me rehni lagi Or apna beta ko v😒
@Surabhi, all Akshara’s nonsense will be put on her condition but Akshara’s fans won’t consider Birla’s condition as it was Akshara herself who created the situation. Akshara has acted stupidly and nothing can justify his thoughtless actions.
SMH🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
Aarohi is a selfish woman I would like to say one thing if aarohi expects abhimanyu to leave abhir then i think she should leave roohi. This woman has not made 1 attempt to understand roohi. Why the hell abhimanyu and all cant say her the truth
Sai is soooo better thn akshu.. Ek to she left CN without any fault upar se she actually had no one to go isliye akeli thi upar se koi fake baap ko real baap nai banayi savi ka.. Infact she was ok with virat visiting sai often nd after marrying satya she clearly told savi that her father will always be virat only and she can call satya as uncle or sabse badi baat sai victim nai khelti kabhi
@Surabhi it’s an insult to Sai to be compared to Akshara, Akshara never knew how to make a single right decision but what irritated me about Sai was his affection for Vinu.
Wow! Now even a mother’s love is question🙄🙄🙄 call urself a mother🙄🙄🙄 even Abhi can claim his right to Abhir what’s wrong with Sai’s love for her son?🙄🙄🙄 I pity ur children😌😌😌
@WTH it’s me pity you actually if you find the nonsense shown in his shows as normal. Sai decided to enter a relationship for the whims of a child, doing this won’t get him Vinu’s love, you can see the love behind Sai’s action but it’s not good for a child to believe that adults are ready to fulfill all their whims, to please them. Believe what you want if it sings to you to teach your own children to treat you like a toy and take advantage of your feelings, do it if you wish 🤭
No need to pity me, I KNOW what I am seeing, I see as a mother you call urself but have NEVER actually show some humanity to children, from Akshara saving those orphanage children n other incident like went into the forest followed a boy whose life was at stake, clearly show ur heartless, so it is pityful that your children has mother like you! PERIODT!! NOT GOING TO ANSWER YOU WHATEVER!!! CIAO🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭
@WTH, stay in your inner stupidity, interfere into a criminal case unprepared or you could have just contacted the proper authorities is sentencing someone to death what happened, even one of the children Akshara wanted to save could have been killed,
Manjiri was Niel’s mother, her son died because of Akshara’s stupidity, but of course you won’t sympathize with her, will you? really hypocrisy, and you talk about humanity, what a joke. And Save a child in the forest she did not even know the perimeters and the dangers of the forest, she also did not know where to orient because she did not know the topography of the forest, called for help or a guard forester would have killed him? she almost committed suicide and if she had found the child who can say if she would not have put him in danger by delaying him with his state of health. you are irredeemable in your stupidity. Some people should think before they act to avoid causing problems for others and themselves, the real danger is acting without thinking.😒
@yeol
Many are feeling Akshara did some great job but in my POV, she did the most stupid and foolish thing. There’s a reason people say “Don’t work hard, work smart”. Some even want her to get bravery awards🥴 She never used her brain before taking a decision and brought only destructions. What a shame to Akshara Singhania and Naira legacy.
@.., Akshara never showed wisdom, she is the heroine of this series but she never did anything that could be inspiring on the contrary she piled up mistakes in a thoughtless way.
I don’t know why but I see this custody case as part of Akshara’s journey. If the case went according to the well established facts, then Abhimanyu is winning this, no kidding. Now this isn’t the any run-of-the-mill story. This is Akshara’s story so I think some fanciful twists are planned. Now Abhimanyu and his family are positioned not as Goenka opponents, but as Sharma’s. That was what I got here in the write-up or update. So I don’t look at Abhinav’s refusal to collect Abhimanyu’s jinxed money in isolation. The PH has been posing this as a fight between rich and middle class since the beginning which is where this track is going. The opening scene and the closing scene have this recurring theme. Hardly to be missed. That’s why I called it a fight between might and magic. The magic is the part where inspiration meets the hardwork of the Sharmas.
Infact this track and sequential ones will lead to August, thinking Independence Day and Raksha Bandhan Day. I’m interpolating this from the key events of today’s episode. The visit of Neela Aama, means no more return to Kasauli, this was hinted at for days and corroborated on screen. I’m hoping to see messages of self-reliance and self-respect through out. Eventually Abhinav is likely to be shown making it. So there there’s some messaging to the viewers.
Aarohi was bound to take matters into her hands soon enough. The Birlas didn’t see this possibility but they have pushed her to act on her worst behaviour. Manjiri isn’t seeing the dangers of what she’s doing yet. Mahima and Aarohi could see it. Not talking about the lavishness mentioned or increased importance of Abhir, but the presumption of thinking that Abhir’s homecoming is a done deal. Abhimanyu was pensive throughout but unable to put in the word of caution to his mother’s exuberance. I continue to see a possibility of Mahima throwing a spanner in the works in this grand plan of her sister. Aarohi’s strategy isn’t a proper sword fight yet, it is like playing with sticks. I would be afraid that these elaborate plans of Manjiri would be sabotaged by people from the Birla house.
@Francis
I agree. How can there be no Kasauli anymore? Unless Nav character dies, or Abhir come to hate his parents, Kasauli is bound to happen again.
Yes this is a fight between sharmas and birlas with a side dish of Goenkas.
In matters of Abhir, Birla house looks divided and this is not ideal for a child upbringing. Parents needs to show a united front for a child to have proper upbringing. Here Manjiri is way past her qualifications. Its like she entered new territory but she thinks she knows all the corners of said territory. Is this right? Just few days back, she was shunning Abhir away, but today she is showering Abhir with lots of affections at once. I dont know who will bring her back to her senses?
@Francis, you disentangle the yarn well.
@Francis I like ur analysis here👍
@Francis. I completely agree with you. With custody battle both birls and sharmas started to see the problems in a larger picture and will try to sort out it amending their ways. I think custody battle will be withdrawn by Abhimanyu later following to Abhinav granting coparenting rights to Abhi. Now all of them are in their journey of realization to find out where they Exactly went wrong.
@Mark.
Yes I think Abhinav hiring a cab here, and the pending, still pending heart surgery, and the custody case and potential trial for Abhir’s custody, means that the Sharmas will be in Udaipur for the foreseeable future. But it is possible that they may visit Neela Aama in Kasauli. Now they will be based in Udaipur I think.
This is where Birla family though advantaged, may lose this case. They aren’t together. Manjiri should keep her emotions in check but she isn’t doing that. Her stance is likely to force the likes of Parth, Mahima, Aarohi or even Ruhi to stand against Abhir’s entry to the Birla house. This is from the inside. The Sharmas will try to find any evidence that Abhir wouldn’t be well taken care of in that house and they will find some at this rate.
I guess only Abhimanyu can bring her back from the brink, she means well no doubt about that, but she is endangering her grandson, and that too without realising it.
@Rai.
Thanks a lot. We are seeing emerging patterns. Muskaan, Abhinav’s rakhi sister is gaining influence in the Goenka family. Ruhi, Abhir’s cousin sister, in the Birla house is growing antagonistic to Abhir. There are subtle hints within the episodes about what’s going on. Let’s see how the story progresses.
@PO.
Thanks for enjoying it. I just tried to understand the updates well and gave my thoughts concerning those.
@Nitu.
True. Both families are moving towards realising where they win the custody case, however in essence they are moving towards a settlement. Abhimanyu doesn’t want to hurt Akshara and Abhinav unnecessarily, a fact that hasn’t been picked up but which has been there for days. If a withdrawal of the custody case happens as you posit, then that will suddenly allow goodwill to form between Abhimanyu and Akshara. I look forward to what happens next.
Why makers are showing it as rich vs poor rather thn biological father vs loving father? Rich are not always bad and poor are not always good.. Makers ko lagta hai ye amiri garibi shit dikhane se viewers will sympathize with akshnav and see abhimanyu as villain.. May be some viewers but not all.. Akshu chose to be poor despite having rich helpful family and wants the same for abhir too😒
@Surabhi.
Yes the makers have some inspirational messages and the examples they give or portray don’t neatly fall into good or bad types as you put out. Everywhere people are thrilled at rag to riches stories and they may be building that here. This is where they are carefully moving the bits forward. I am careful in my comments too as I used opponents and not adversaries or enemies, which are another level all together. So they are competing like @Mark duly commented elsewhere. Viewers shouldn’t see it as a good versus evil rivalry, because they will then miss some of the morale of the story. Abhimanyu and Akshara got here on a misunderstanding and their actions based on their convictions built a huge wedge between them. Many here comment that neither is right or wrong. However, I think Abhimanyu will be misunderstood by a lot of people, just as Akshara will in equal measure. I try to see the whole picture and the way the story is built up and this makes me enjoy what they are trying to tell.
@Francis
I agree again. This is about rich father and middle class father who is rich in self-reliance and self-respect. They both love Abhir and both wish to provide Abhirs desires. Soon they will learn to work together interms of financially supporting Abhirs amenities, rather than each making plans separately.
I agree Akshara or Nav and Manyu cannot be termed as adversaries or enemies rather as opposers of views and goals.
I also agree that Manyu and Akshu are always misunderstood by people, in different situations. The whole point is not whether Akshu or Manyu is right or wrong but rather the how all characters respond to all the events leading to, and after a certain good or bad decision. If Akshu is wrong, then how did the rest of the characters influence this wrong action? All involved must be viewed in the same spectrum as Akshu viceversa with rest of the characters
I dont know if the above comment is correct but i feel it makes sense.
Yes! @Surabhi you are right the word ” choose” n why? Everyone has the freedom to choose what is appropriate for them at that very moment, and ofc she choose to be right at that very moment!
@Mark.
I concur readily. You have put it out very is for
r sure. well indeed. The fight isn’t just between rights of blood and rights of upbringing, there’s the dimension of that of rich and middle-class. And you have explained that. The interactions between Akshara-Abhinav and Abhimanyu are where the story can be untangled. I seek to understand how those play out because they have intense interactions or competitive ones but no dangerous ones, and there isn’t going to be any adversarial interaction here, that for sure.
Please tell me… which era the Goenka’s are living in? All that’s left for this backward serial is for someone to commit sati 🙄 I really hope Akshu wins… this is a fight between the middle class and the rich… promiseManyu will spoil our lovely Abhir and turn him into a nut case much like himself. As for this Arohi, when will her braincells wake up so she can realise what Akshara already has about the Birla’s and free herself and Ruhi from them. I think it’s going to take Ruhi saying she doesn’t want to live with PromiseManyu and Manjiri for Arohi to agree and leave that house. I want to see a strong Arohi standing up for her daughter and only her daughter. As for Shefali I wonder if she can see the hypocrisy in how Manjiri wants her son to be with her but Abhir to be away from Akshara… they are even spoiling the side characters… I really hope the kids are freed from these toxic Birla’s soon and reconnect
@Jade.
Me as well. I like Akshara-Abhinav side of the story as there is inspiration, or aspirational qualities there. I think that the makers have positioned it this way middle-class versus rich to make the custody case winnable from the Akshara side. If it’s about the biological father and the stepfather then the case strengthens in favour of Abhimanyu. The Birlas receive a lot of flak for their actions which are inconsistent as has been pointed out. Now Shefali as you’ve mentioned is in Manjiri’s gratitude and she isn’t able to speak up in favour of Akshara. I don’t know if there is a plan for the Aarohi character, it’s just there, not interacting with even the Goenkas. I hope that the ambiguity is resolved soon. I think that she has to make a pathway for herself that gives her the optimum potential. Staying at the Birlas isn’t going to be in her long-term interest.
Now the issue is rich vs poor. But as for custody, there is still some other topics like psychic evaluation e.t.c, which will affect the dynamics of the hearings.
Shefali is clinging to Manjiri for dear life. She thinks Manjiri will help her still. But i wonder if Shefali decides to open her custody hearing at the same time Manyus on progress, what side will Manjiri choose? If its shefalis, then her sons custody will be sabotaged by Mahima. Its wont be the first time Mahima did something to avenge Manjiri for something she did that affected her.
As for Arohi, she has fear that her wedding may not happen. But incase she could have married Manyu before Abhir truth is out, i dont know what could be her position regarding her husbands child from his previous marriage.
@Francis Aarohi did called Surekha but of all the person Surekha haha🤣
@PO.
It’s amusing. She was afraid there and she went to Surekha. Isn’t it better to go to a signboard that reads help? At least the silence there would be dignified and one may find an idea or two to turn the situation around. Surekha wants to unify Akshara and Abhimanyu for some unknown reason. Aarohi seems to have lost touch with her house or she would have known this already.
Oh god, I just started watching after seeing Abhinav and love him! Figured would come here and read some nice comments about Abhinav lekin yeh Abhira fans toh 🤢🤮 at least there are some fans with actual brains that like Abhinav and Akshara, myself included!
Sorry, but Abhinav made a stupid move by not taking Rs. 500. In the same episode, he’s calculating future expenses when Abhir would be in 12th grade, etc. and feeling anxious about earning enough, & then he does these stunts, when he actually gets money. Facepalm. Really stupid. Please, someone teach Abhinav to keep personal and professional life, different. He needs to remain calm and manage his emotions, and act professionally and maturely, and accept all the money, with self-respect. The stunts he’s doing right now, are Facepalm and cringy moves, lacking maturity and self-respect. He doesn’t respect his work, when he decides to give back his hard earned money.