Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai 16th August 2023 Written Episode, Written Update on TellyUpdates.com
The Episode starts with Akshu crying. She hears Abhinav calling her and goes out. She says I can hear your voice but not see you. She looks at the mirror. She recalls her mangalsutra and sindoor. She hears his voice. She shuts ears. Manish comes and holds her. She gets scared. He asks what happened. She says I feel I m going mad, I feel he is with me, I know he won’t come, I hear his voice. He says it’s a big sorrow, there are many phases, first one is denial then anger, third one is to bargain, person thinks something should have happened instead this, once you learn living with this pain, maybe this pain gets less. She says yes, you said everything right, just one thing wrong, I m on second step, I have anger in me right now, we didn’t deserve this, whatever happened with me and Abhir, Abhi will get punished, I will not leave him.
Abhi meets his family outside the court. Anand says we are with you. Parth says don’t be scared. Abhi says Maa, you trust Kanha ji, I trust Mahadev, truth will come out, don’t worry. Inspector asks him to come. Akshu comes with family. Abhi says I know its difficult for you, how is Abhir. She says Abhir’s father is no more, he doesn’t have his father now. Abhi cries. Abhir says dad can’t stay without talking to me. Ruhi says I will talk to poppy. She calls Abhi and says its switched off, they are hiding something from us. He says we have to find out. The court hearing begins. Kairav, Muskaan, Manish and everyone give statements. Muted….
Abhir says I have to change clothes. He pulls a tshirt. The clothes fall down. He says mumma will scold me. He gets Abhinav’s phone. He says dad is in Kasauli, how is he messaging me if his phone is here. Abhi looks at everyone. Abhir says I will ask mumma. Ruhi comes. He shows the phone. She asks are you sure, how can the phone come. He says I will ask mumma why did she lie. She says it means she doesn’t want to tell you something. He says yes, they are hiding something big, but why would they lie, I m getting a bad feeling, is dad fine. Ruhi says come with me. judge says court has recorded the statements of the witnesses, the court is adjourned till tomorrow. Manjiri says don’t repeat my mistake, Akshara, please don’t punish someone for the sorrow of losing someone. Abhi says its okay, I know my truth, it will come out. Inspector takes him. Ruhi and Abhir pray to Kanha ji. She says we will know everything now. Inspector says we have taken the blood samples of the culprit for alcohol test, don’t worry, inform us if you know anything else. Akshu thanks him. Abhir asks why did police come home. Ruhi asks is Abhinav lost.
He says no, he remembers all the routes. She says police uncle came when you were also lost, everyone is worried. He says call docman, he doesn’t hide anything. She says no, I m upset, his phone isn’t reachable. He calls Abhi. He thinks what to do now. Manjiri asks what’s there in this envelope, why are you crying. Abhi says birthday gift for Sharma ji, Abhir’s custody. She says you wanted to legally give Abhir to them. He says yes, I thought Sharma ji will happily hug me. She says don’t worry, nothing bad will happen with you, I will speak to the lawyer. Abhi says don’t know how is Akshu handling Abhir. He prays for them. Akshu sees the clothes fallen. Abhir looks on. She asks how did the clothes fall. He says I was taking my tshirt. She says its okay. He asks won’t you scold me. She says no, you are young, you won’t get scolded, you go now. He says no, I will help you. Ruhi looks on. Abhir keeps the phone between the clothes. Akshu sees the phone and gets relieved. Ruhi signs Abhir. Abhir thinks to ask once. Akshu says Abhir, I forgot to tell you, your dad called, you were sleeping that time, he wanted to talk to you. He asks shall I call him now. She says yes, you can call, he told me that he is busy, we will call tomorrow. He thinks why is mumma lying, please tell me where is my dad.
Precap:
Akshu asks what shall I do. Manish says we have to tell the truth to the kids. Abhir and Ruhi see the garlands on Abhinav’s pic. Abhir asks Akshu about the garlands on Abhinav’s pic.
Update Credit to: Amena
152 Comments
Alright, onto the second whitewash on stage. So Abhimanyu was really planning to gift Abhir custody to Abhinav…mmhm. If the creators truly aimed to make neutral viewers warm up to Abhimanyu, they should have concluded Abhinav’s storyline differently. They could’ve shown Abhimanyu realizing his mistakes and trying to make things better for Abhir and Akshara. The decision to involve Abhimanyu in Abhinav’s death scene was a bad idea. No matter how hard they try now, the question remains the same. Why did he take Abhinav to a cliff and served him alcohol? especially just hours before the birthday celebration when everyone was eagerly waiting for him? why did Abhimanyu refrain from drinking any alcohol himself? There are a bunch of questions, and I’m not sure if Abhimanyu can give believable answers. The creators have kind of messed up Abhimanyu’s character to the point where it’s hard to fix. They tried to make Abhimanyu look like a victim who’s being accused for no reason, but they just created a mess that makes people who think logically doubt his intentions. The only way Abhimanyu can clear things up now is by showing a video that he took before Abhinav’s death in which he says he wants to drink alcohol on a cliff to get the Kasauli vibe. If he can’t do that, he will be remembered as a foolish doctor who ended up unintentionally killing someone because of his foolishness.
@Sara. True. Now any such act of abhi won’t make him a victim. A big ‘No’ for sympothy from the neutral viewers. The more they go for a whitewash, it won’t work only disappointment will get with this character. They have ruined abhi’s character and still doing it now giving the label a victim. If reasonable answers can be given then we can accept his intensions were not bad but i don’t find any answer is there to justify his act.
”
The only way Abhimanyu can clear things up now is by showing a video that he took before Abhinav’s death in which he says he wants to drink alcohol on a cliff to get the Kasauli vibe.” Ok.. if this is a case then only one question gets an answer. But what about the rest. Though it was abhinav’s wish why abhi took him for a dronk before the party? He could have arranged it some other time. Why abhi didn’t have the drink? Still they are not answered. For abhi no sympothy but a disappointment bcz they have ruined that character.
@Sara if they wanted to end his character there was a more peaceful way with disease or something, they could have shown Manyu with the Sharma’s looking after Nav and making sure he’s comfortable and not in pain while he makes a few last memories with his family, that would have warmed the neutrals and Nav and NavRa fans to him but here we see Manyu not even mourning but making his Akshara jaap, instead of worrying about Nav his mind was fully focused on Akshu and Abhir
@Jade
The answer is, Manyu is a psychopath. I am really getting psychopathic vibes from him.
@Sara
True. Manyu is a foolish and feebleminded doctor that unintentionally led caused Navs death. Apart from treating the sick, Manyu knows nothing else. He is a dummy if it’s not about the human anatomy.
Honestly, I just want him to admit Infront of everyone that his psychopathic tendencies took Nav on a cliff hours before his party(hosted by his son), to drink. If the reason is not his psychopathic personality, then schizophrenia like @jade suggested.
@Mark ur right, at least show Abhimanyu regrets that he brought Abhinav to the cliff! Or apologised to Akshara for bringing Abhinav to the cliff, but no he is asking about Abhir instead which obviously is not well!
@Sara
True. I would have geniunely felt bad for toxicmanyu if he felt guilt and regretted all his selfish activities.
@Sara
Exactly!!!
Now he is worried about Nav’s widow🙄. Where was this worry 6 years ago when she was physically, mentally and emotionally hurt. Agreed you were mourning over Neil’s death. After that not even one minute in that 6 years you took time to realise that AK is hurt??? But you PATHETICALLY cry,tell poems, do stand up comedy on your failure of love life and portray as if you are the only victim like a road side Romeo Loverboy.
@Sara.
Agreed. His character has been severely damaged by his role in Abhinav’s death. Yes, big twists are on the pipeline, but how do they fix this unintended or intended damage? .
Take a look. If he made Aarohi his confidant about this custody settlement review or whatever it is, he wouldn’t have fallen into this trouble. He likes to work alone. Now, he knew that his mother wouldn’t agree to this. So not an option. I sympathise here, reluctantly. Probably on the day that Manish saw him on the phone with the hushed voice, he was finalising the details with the lawyer. On the other hand, when Abhinav was trapped in the drug case, Akshara happened to be in the know, which probably saved him from a lengthy jail term.
Now, his mother is trying to reach out to Harshvardhan. Desperate times call for desperate measures.
I know Abhimanyu will somehow miraculously come out of detention, but will the makers be able to sell a convincing story about why it happened?
Exacyly! @Francis
Exactly*
Manjiri said wat? Don’t make the same mistake like her, don’t punish someone for the lost of someone?? Coz the someone now that is lost is not related to you? And the accused is ur loved one? Absurb!
@Soo
Rightly said
@Soo Exactly! She punished Akshara after accusing her of Neil’s death. In this case, there are witnesses and other evidences present and the witnesses are her own people, so how can she allow Abhimanyu to escape punishment? Manjiri would have acted similarly if there were even a slight piece of evidence against Akshara regarding Neil’s death. She seems to have forgotten how she sent a court notice to Akshara, instructing her to stay away from Abhir. Her actions define hypocrisy.
Right! @Sara
@Sara Makers wanted end Abhinav character I think they mighty have some classes btw makers ,writers how to end character……….. Writers story different from Rs point if view it clearly showing Abhinav character end it’s suddenly took it not preplan if it’s preplan they concluded Abhinav character well right or they making us fools🤔 Hindi drama shows doesn’t have logic.is it necessary every time Ml ,Fl reunion? Ml starting all bad boys qualities then redeeming final is it necessary? Since long back Abhimanyu character emotionalless according to scenes maybe not interested?only Ak character has showing emotions less/more 🤔🤨….Did u saw Wallposter they removed Abhir pics too ,they show only Ak abhi pics that means Abhir also exit?Which way story going on?Once they decide Abhira reunion makers do what ever….!!!!!!????
Like Akshara’s, even my eyes were looking for abhinav. I too couldn’t able to accept the truth that he won’t come again. And still my eyes are waiting to see him….Abhinav…
Haa..haa.. birthday gift. Abhi already gave a gift, now what he is getting sad for. Was he wanted to give the gift after making him drink too much🤔. Yes, Abhir’s custody would be the best gift for abhinav. But what was the need of that early 🥃 celebration when the real happiness has yet to come. Why couldn’t he first give the gift at the party infront of everyone and then after the party celebrate. Oh.. pls world sympotheis him. He is crying now remembering sharmaji. He is worrying now for that he couldn’t give the gift. He is sad. Pls world try your best to sympotheis and forgive him.
No matter what gift he planned to give, the questions that need answers still remain.
@Lily True, I watched some old episodes yesterday, especially the one in which Abhinav and Abhir were excited about going to Udaipur. However, the makers ended up destroying everything – from Abhimanyu’s character to the happy, perfect Sharma family. They had the potential to improve this show, but they chose to mess it up. I’m still finding it hard to believe that we won’t be able to see Abhinav anymore. He was such a nice person, and his positivity will be greatly missed especially his lame jokes. Now, it seems like this show is going to be filled with negativity. It’s about time for Akshara to disclose the truth to Abhir. Regardless of whether he finds out today or tomorrow, the outcome will be the same. I just hope he won’t ask Akshara to withdraw the case and it’s better to keep him away from this court drama.
@Lily, he could have given the custody papers on the cliff itself without getting Nav sloshed 😔 wonder what DKPs angle is 🙄 I too am missing Nav, especially him cuddling his NikkiJi
@Lily
Exactly. There are questions that need to be answered no matter how much Manyu cries or in which pitiable state he is in, Manyu needs to answer those questions.
@Lily
True.Abhinav’s “Jeena chahta hoon…..”, still hits me.
@Lily I couldn’t accept myself also Abhinav is no more 😭 just like Ak &you 😭😭😭 when Ak thought Abhinav calling her, Ak call him back Abhinav I was like😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 each and every time seriously my eyes watery 😭😭…I really missed Abhinav character ,Akshnav touches , Akshnavir 👨👩👦 Bonding …..I know Abhinav gone but….
I couldn’t understand how far Abhira reunion possibly?Indian dramas anything can be possible 🤔but….why?So many ?but no proper explanation? every thing showing according Ml point of view not Abhinav point of view…..confusion 🤨
No concerns no guilt of Abhinav death 😤
Good things happen with Bad people like abhi
Bad things happen with good people like Abhinav 😭😭
Akshara should decide who’s? What? At least Ak justified What Akshnav fans want! We hopping…if it didn’t happen it a unfair to Abhinav sacrifice!!!!???
Either she becomes Birla doormat or Abhinav pride?
this sh*t is still running 💀
the last i saw was the leads hanging from a tree with the fl in an ugly red dress….wonder what all happened in between 😂😂😂💀
@Washma That’s precisely why some people refer to their romance as “cringe.” I couldn’t help but laugh upon reading your response…..leads hanging from a tree, lol. I caught a glimpse of that scene where Abhimanyu was reminiscing about his memories with Akshara while he was returning from Kasauli to Udaipur and I was like “WTF?”.
This is an immortal show, even if you return after 40 years, it’s likely that the show will still be ongoing, with new leads and even a 15-20 generation leap. This crap began when I was in 3rd grade, and now I’m a college graduate, yet it’s still being aired.
It’s the credit of YRKKH to stay so strong and so long👍👍👍 no doubt! Although people here complain about it, but yet they are still watching and supporting, isn’t it??? Sorry no offense🙏
@ washma Best thing happen gen3 Abhinav character ,Akshnav pure ❤️ moments not like main leads love ,Akshnavir moments also watchable 🥰 rest is nothing bla bla……
That Abhi manyu has no remorse of his actions whatsoever… he is still hovering over Akshara and Abhir… Dhatt…
Exactly @Anu
Exactly, he didn’t once repent as to why he took his so called friend to that deadly place. His Akshara jaap is so annoying… If now under any circumstances this so called mahan akshara goes back to to that shameless man, then shame on this long lasting serial. They better go off air.
@Anu Exactly! If he had any remorse of his actions, the first thing he would’ve done is apologize to Akshara but no, he just wants to know how they are. He wanted Akshara to apologize to Manjiri but he can’t do it. As I mentioned above both mom and son are definitions of hypocrisy.
@SK I know! At this point, there is a clear boundary between Akshara and Abhimanyu, which is difficult to overcome. Typically, television shows follow a predictable pattern for such storylines, but in this case, things unfolded quite differently. Unlike other shows, Akshara married Abhinav, they found happiness together, and she was prepared to move forward. Abhimanyu and Akshara experienced intense conflicts, and now Abhimanyu is facing accusations regarding her husband’s death. Unlike other shows, where children usually choose to be with their biological parent once they learn the truth, Abhir expressed a desire to remain with Abhinav even after discovering the reality. Reuniting Abhira seems like it will be a forced outcome, given the absence of love and trust in their relationship.
@ Anu it’s not big deal to him now When Abhinav was alive you didn’t see how he doing things in middle of Muskan marriage …. how Abhinav was discomfort 🥺 he eliminate Abhinav in Ak life . In the Abhinav presences he was act like saint ……Now he is just waiting come out of jail that’s it he won’t wait for single minutes to cuddle her if Ak put a boundaries to him , otherwise by hook or by crook he would make her doormat even his mother too.Shameless people 😤
He said Abhinav was his brother so 🤮🤮🤮🤮 his actions are not look like concern…..Abhimanyu Birla you’re …….
I need the bleach DKP is using maybe it can get the Turmeric stains of my damn dish towels!!!
Sharma ji is my friend, I was giving Sharma Ji custody but mofo answer WHY you got him sloshed on a cliff 2 hours before his party. Someone was saying Nav was asking for alcohol maybe, even if he was it was Manyu’s responsibility to look after him and not get him sloshed, Abhir wanted to go to the game zone with Nav but Manyu took him to the cliff…. I still think he wanted to make Nav make a fool of himself but it backfired (well his other darker self did, I still see Manyu as schizophrenic, bipolar and undergoing depression, when bipolar people have an episode and if you can stick by them through it then you are a better person than most) the moment I hear this person has mental struggles I’m like naah I don’t need that smoke.
I just feel bad for Abhir it’s going to hurt him even more, he has been hungering for his Papa and when he learns the truth it will hit him even harder. The kids will find out the truth on their own. I think Nav might have made a voice note while Manyu was getting down the cliff to him saying he drank and fell and Manyu wasn’t at fault BUT he does bear some responsibility and so does Birla hospital for malpractice. We’ve seen the Goenka’s mourn Nav but none of the Birla’s and what is the wife beater Parth walking around free for, he should be in the cell next to Manyu. Where is Mahima 🤔 she has not been seen for weeks, are they going to show her bringing back Harsh to fix Manyu’s life 🤔
I feel they will end Akshu after the next leap and she will be United with Nav on the other side, people were saying Akshu doesn’t love Nav and she only feels gratitude and respect towards him, I hope they understand now that NavRa had a deep bond of love cemented in respect and friendship, and it’s something Akshu will hold dearly in her heart, she’ll love again hopefully it’s herself.
@Jade
I am with you on the bipolar and schizophrenic being the reason for why Manyu does what he does.
True, Manyu and Nav and Birla hospital are responsible for Navs death. But Manyu was like, “yes I did that, and no one will do anything to me”, when Kairav was giving his testimony. Manyu irks me to no end. He thinks he is invincible and great than all. I hope makers will slap him down to earth to grovel and struggle like the rest of us mortals. Him losing everything including Akshara’s respect and trust will be a start.
@Jade.
“I need the bleach DKP is using maybe it can get the Turmeric stains of my damn dish towels!!!” 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 DKP should start marketing it. He will get more profit than showing these toxicities. And
Agree 100%. Even I had the feeling that they will end up Akshara’s character soon and will unite her with abhinav and complete their incomplete eternal love story. While abhi meets a girl whose lookalike to akshara but not with the personality. New Akshara will be a perfect match for abhi and abhi will finally get abbir toy with him. and marrying this new girl will raise abhir. I don’t know about ruhi. May be arohi also might gt killed so that abhi can have both toys. Though it will be the same story like in gen2, this might be a way to shut those abhira and manyu stans mouths😂🤪. Seing Akshara’s love towards abhinav which she even didn’t feel for abhi, now those stans have become more rude and they are now out of control with thier anger and hatred.
@Lily that’s awful, I’d rather Manyu dies too and he can stand on the crossroads of the afterlife with Arohi going to Neil and Akshu going to Nav and him just stuck…. It would be better if Ruhi and Abhir are raised by MusKai, they can have a flashy new kid for the next gen called Muskara 😂😂😂
True @Jade. What I told is the most awlful and pathetic end. How can our man child have a end like that😄😄. But seing how this story narrated from the news on abhinav’s death seems like writers have started to console abhira and manyu stans. Their main target has become to make those happy and not to come up with better script. So such ending is not a surprise😄😄😄
@Jade
“I hope they understand now that NavRa had a deep bond of love cemented in respect and friendship”
They will never understand. So no use hoping also.For them finger licking, cheek rubbing, weird soul connection🙄, after 6 years also PATHETICALLY asking married ex wife is true love.
@ Lily @Jade Fans of Abhira might not agree because I’ve seen a few people commenting that Akshara’s Sharma family seems fake for taking Abhimanyu’s child away. Some believe Akshara’s feelings for Abhinav are just about caring and nothing more. It’s confusing to understand the show they’re watching, as recent episodes clearly show Akshara’s love for Abhinav.
“Abhi says its okay, I know my truth, it will come out”
I wonder how he will prove that🤔🤔 Mahadev miracle? Will Mahadev bring Nav from death and make him tell what happened. Then will Nav tell that ‘i wanted to drink and bhaiji brought it, i wanted to go to a cliff to enjoy and celebrate but bhiaji refused and finally bhaiji said ok coz i insisted him to go, then I per my wish emptied the bottle and i went closer to the edge and slipped but my bhaiji tried his best to save me. He is innocent’ 🤷♀️
Since writers have given the dialogue truth will come out, they might have answers for the questions. Hope they won’t be illogical reasonings. 😂😂😂 Abhi’s expression when Muskaan was giving her statement. It was like “hey silly girl.. iam your instant brother. What the hell you are doing? You are blaming for your instant brother. I helped you in your marriage. Have you forgotten them? Is this the way you treat to ur instant bhai?”🤦♀️ Today even Arohi didn’t stand by his side and was abhi expecting that at least she would be with him?
@Meily, I admire Arohi for sticking with her sister, it gives me hope that there is no cringe romance and the reality of 2 widowed sisters bonding and supporting each other in raising their kids together. I hope this gen ends with Abhir and Ruhi qualifying as doctors and giving a speech about how their mothers brought them up alone that is far more beautiful than any romance.
@Jade
What was Aruhis facial expression when she was leaving? Because I saw like she was guilty for taking Goenkas side.
Remember when Akshara used to take her family side and be there for them? She was being reprimanded by both Manyu and Manjiri. I wonder how Aru can stand by her family now.
@Mark. Her expressions looked like that she feels sorry that this time she cannot take his side. But some where she too might have the questions we are having and not that he pushed abhinav. She too might believe that abhi had no intension to kill abhinav but she too needs answers for the doubts she is having so she is quite. The doubts she is having might not let her take abhi’s side as she knows abhi has a responsibility on abhinav’s death.
@Lily
So Arus POV is like that of the audience? Specifically, @surabhis. Because Aru is a great fan of Manyu and now she too is doubtful.
@Meily
Exactly. When Mus was giving her statement and when Kai was too. Looks like I wasn’t the only one that noticed that.
Oooh! So now, Manyu is the beacon of innocence?😏 Bullshit! You cannot gift someone, something you don’t deserve. Impossible. Something that you don’t deserve, is snatched from you without waiting for you to generously gift it out. In other words, Manyu cannot gift the custody of Abhir to Navra. Navra should take Abhirs custody, that too, in a legal way!!!!Which world is yrkkh living in?💆 So Navra was waiting for Manyu to generously give up Abhirs custody? So what if he later gets a change of heart and decides to keep Abhir with him? Akshara has always been dumb and I am tired expecting anything from her. So Akshara is staying with Abhir merely due to Manyus verbal permission? What about the verdict? The special order? Is she even a lawyer? Does she know anything about law? All this time, she was waiting for Manyu to grow a pair and give up his custody?
Anyways, forget about this dumbShara. Why is Manjiri and Manyu emotionally manipulating dumbShara? Is Akshara the one that brought about the case? No right? So what’s up with Manjiri folding her hands Infront of Akshara and calling her beti, and all that emotional talk? My point is, Manjiri should fold her hands to all Goenkas family. First to Manish who saw Manyu pushing Nav, then to Mus for seeing Manyu offering Nav alcohol, then to Kairav for calling the police. Akshara has nothing to do with the case and it’s absurd that she is the one being begged as if she holds the key to Manyu being a murderer. (@Rr, we audience know he is not a murderer but the cause for Navs death. But Goenkas know he is a murderer only and nothing to do with leading Navs to his death. So I am following the POV of Goenkas and not audience POV). Infact, it’s Manyus fault that he is being accused in the first place. Manyu behaved suspiciously and shady, and he trapped HIMSELF in this case. Manish fell in Manyus trap and thus became the vessel that put in motion this case. And Manyus attitude today! Ooh God, makes me wanna think that he is not remorseful for being the means to wipe Nav from the face of the earth. And Aruhi!! What is the meaning of that expression of hers??? I don’t understand her. She is feeling guilty for Manyus situation? I hope she is feeling that as she knows Ruhis poppy is innocent and nothing else. Even then, it means she doesn’t believe what Manish is claiming. If that is the case, why not talk to Manish about it?
And if Makers dare to put in motion a repeat of 6yrs ago, then they better do it right. Manjiri making efforts to warn Akshara of the consequences of acting on rage, shouldn’t hinder the replay of the entire events of 6yrs ago. I mean to say, Manyu should loose everything before he is found to be innocent. Manyu should loose his reputation, respect as a doctor, his hospital should go bankrupt, he should be branded a murderer for life. Only after all this, should he be found innocent. And when that time comes, Akshara should go to him and say “sorry”, so that we can see if that will help.
@Mark
💯💯💯👏. They are trying to show toxicmanyu a saint who sacrificed everything for happiness of others. But we all know under what circumstances sperm donor gave up on abhir. He literally mental abused the kid, treated him like a toy, prioritised his and his mom’s pain over his own son leading that poor kid to ran and finally without a choice he gave so that he could escape from the licence of “abuser” I couldn’t even feel 0.1 percent mercy on him now.
I agree. I don’t understand why even ask them to drop the case…like Hun this isn’t
a theft or assault case that u can drop if the other party wants, it’s a MURDER CASE , a person was killed, n the govt/police r responsible to punish the criminal in order to prevent future crime that might be committed again by the same person. Now all the birlas can do is find a solid evidence proving manyu’s innocence… N this dude idk how he became a doctor, with what common sense. He’s like he knows the truth n mahadev will help. BRO it doesn’t matter if u know the truth , other’s have to know it, the judge has to know it to let you go free. And I don’t think he knows but the entirety of goenka’s have statements against him and they even have proof so unless a miracle happens n Manish remembers he saw wrong or if they find a solid video evidence only then can they prove his innocence.
@Sirna very correct!!the case is filed by police for murder and goenkas are only witnesses for prosecution.Its upto the judge to decide
@Msdism and @sirna
Exactly. Manyu is a joke. He is acting as if someone didn’t just die and he is being suspected of killing him. What Manyu is going through is child’s play. Infact, it’s usual to get suspected of doing something. He shouldn’t give out statements like, “it’s okay, I know my truth”. Well if you know your truth, then shut the hell up so that others too learn your so called “truth”. Even if it takes forever for Manish to rethink back to what he saw, let him wait till then. He is here thinking this is a joke while others are growing with serious hatred for him.
@ dumbshara😂 how true.Not letting Abhir see Abhinav dead body was still understandable. But was she going to lie to him all her life ? Does she not realise that being his only caregiver she will traumatise him for life, he won’t ever trust her,even now he feels that Abhimanyu will be more truthful🤦♀️.
Waiting to see Manyu dripping with white paint and all spousal abuse being swept up and vacuumed !!
@Rr
Apparently, she doesn’t know how to break it up to him. It’s still understandable. After all, Abhir is smart, he will understand the entire scenario. If Abhir can device a trap to see his mom’s reaction, he can understand too why she lied to him. The thing is, Abhir knows when his mom is lying, and he knows how to deal with his mom. Let them deal with each other.
But I can’t help but feel that Akshara will keep lying about Nav until Manyu comes out and break it to Abhir. That will be white wash part two.
@ Mark I agree with I just wish they sentence abhimanyu then after like 2months in prison that should be enough time for him to reflect on his actions and his life then akshara is going through abhinav phone and sees a video which proves manyu innocent and he is discharged and acquitted then akshara comes to him and say sorry 😹😹 i will love see the face makes
@Fave
How about 20yrs of prison. When he comes out, he will be a grandpa, hence cannot run after any girl. Then Akshara comes to him and says sorry. Then we see how it will help.
@Mark
I agree with every word of yours..she thought of taking Abhir just like that when there is instant special order against her by Manjari…..and with petition in “transit” by Abhimanyu?????
@emoj
Exactly. The petition is no where to be found! Was it really filed? How truthful was Manyu then???
@Mark.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂. If, this could be done earlier and I had argued that it was possible, why didn’t he do it? Anyway the world class heart surgeon interfered with the Sharma family. Only in hindsight can I see that he did. Yes, he tried to fix this, however, this gesture is open to interpretation. Why not give the custody papers to both Abhinav and Akshara? Is it that he is unable to work with the two of them? Questions and more questions.
Although he gave Abhir back, it was his duty to see to it that the legal aspects were fully covered. Now, some excuse about being in depression will crop up. He saw Akshara breakdown after the custody judgement. For me, there and then, he could have hashed out the co-parenting agreement so that the families are in sync with each other. I don’t think that Akshara has much blame here. Abhimanyu almost always takes away the options from in front of Akshara. The last one being on Abhinav’s birthday.
The makers want to take the viewers through this journey so that they have compassion for Abhimanyu. Well, the intentions of Abhimanyu have to be clarified in the next few days. Otherwise this attempt to gain sympathy might not work out.
@Francis
Correct. Manyus gesture is open to interpretation. I am here speculating and speculating but Manyu is over there saying he knows his truth. Well dummy, how about you help me know your truth????? Manyu wants his truth to be coaxed out of him. He is withholding the truth, and if the case spiral to something ugly, Goenkas will look bad.
You are right 100%. Manyu wanted to give Nav Abhirs custody but not Nav and Akshara. Its like he conditioned the gift. I mean to say, Manyu is giving Nav the custody so that when one day Nav is not in the picture, Abhir comes to him. So what about Akshara???? What’s Aksharas part in all this? Does he mean he will with hold the custody to himself now that Nav is gone?
@ Mark I am so confused. The custody battle is between Akshara Sharma vs Abhimanyu Birla.So custody can only be signed over to Akshara.Abhinav can only be given no objection certificate by Abhimanyu to become Abhirs guardian .For all legal purpose Abhimanyu remains Abhir biological father.What are these writers showing🤦♀️
@Mark it should be a gift to Abhir!! As it is Abhir’s wish
@Mark coz Abhimanyu already planned for Abhinav’s exit, so the custody will go back to him after Abhinav’s exit, that is why he give Abhir custody to only Abhinav and not Akshara n Abhinav!🤔🤔
Just one thing I noticed wth was that long eyelock between him and Arohi 🤔🤔🤔I hate it all the time he is chanting akshara and abhir but never once he asked after Roohi🙄🙄
@Ashle
You see what we are going through?💆
@Ashle
Exactly.
That 1 rupee attitude when Aarohi was looking at him clueless, when muskan was giving her testimony 🙄🙄
Washmanyu🤣
😂
😂😂
🤣🤣washmanyu cheapmanyu🤣🤣 guiltymanyu🤣🤣 crymanyu🤣🤣 defendmanyu🤣🤣🤣 manchildmanyu🤣🤣🤣
I suggest everyone to stop watching indian bullsh*t dramas and switch to pakistani dramas instead if you want to be in peace and see something which makes sense.
What kind of bullsh*t they are showing here. Can’t take it anymore
I agree Pakistani drama are good with plot n short or y’all should try K-Drama or J-drama Les number of episodes but a vast variety of genre and good plots. C-drama m not sure cuz out of the ones I watched I’d only recommend a handful.
I am annoyed at the fact that Abhimanyu is still just hovering around Akshara imagine the audacity to ask how she is holding up, how is a woman who recently lost her husband supposed to be especially when her child biological father is one way or the other involved in her husband death . I had expected Abhimanyu to have said the truth about why he took Abirnav to the hill to drink and apologize to Akshara and the goeneka about his own mistakes but he just keeps saying Mahadev will prove his innocence imagine the sense of entitlement.
I wonder if the writers think we the audience are fools , I understand that all of this is fiction but that doesn’t mean they can play with our intelligence, just because they are trying to whitewash Abhimanyu’s character they brought up this gifting of custody to the Sharmas,does the Abhimanyu we all watched in the past few days look like someone who would gift Abhir’s custody to anyone .
Manjiri is simply a hypocrite and all these drama she is doing doesn’t suit her because we all know once all of this court drama is over she will be back to her horrible self once again.
At this point Akshara should just tell the truth to Abhir,it might be hard but he deserves to know and he deserves to grieve his father’s death after all pain is inevitable.
@Ruthie
Exactly. The audacity of Manyu. Manyu has forever acted entitled to everything. Be it Akshara, Abhir and mostly, Mahadevs favors. I know Mahadev will perform a miracle once again.
True, Manyu is not someone who can gift Abhirs custody to anyone for many reasons.
You people are still watching the show😂😂😂 I thought you people will quit after nav’s death😂😂😂
@Surabhi. How should I react😂😂😂🤭🤭🤭😲😲☹️☹️
Any ways..darling..so sorry to see you upset seing the comments here. But um pretty sure the one’s who said they quit have already quit. Do you see their coments here? Coz i don’t find any one yet. Remaining here i don’t remember they told they quit the show after nav’s death but some are here waiting to see abhir’s reaction on learning nav’s death. Please be patience so then you can enjoy your manyu babe’s toxicity and abhira if that happens. Till then you have to tolerate the truth people here comment on manyu babes.😊😉
@no after that you people will say that you all are waiting to see abhimanyu getting punished.. Thn you people will say you all are watching for akshu to go back to kasauli.. Etc etc😂😂😂
@Surabhi. Darling there is a difference between “you all” and “some”. And your 😂 tells about your understanding then.
@Surabhi find me those who said they will quit but are still here?? You for one are sure is still here🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 complaining but watching🤣🤣🤣🤣
@Surabhi SO WHAT?🙄🙄🙄 WE ARE STILL WATCHING N COMMENTING🙄 SO WHAT? WHAT YOU GONNA DO🙄🙄🙄
I am just reading updates to know how Abhir will react. Else nothing interesting is left
Please help me beg them to keep their promise and GET OUT. I am praying for the day they leave here
They all promised to quit the show after their hero’s death, he has been dead for close to a week now and they still come here??? They should please and please keep their promise and leave the show. I am begging them with hands folded like Indian style.
I just wish this wish of yours won’t come true.😉😉 Else you will sink in toxicity and negativity.
I won’t sink dear. I love Abhimanyu no matter how flawed he is. I also respect that he is working on being a better person and I don’t care if your hatred for him makes you blind to it. I would react like him and even more if I were in his shoes. But after some time, I would heal and apologize for my actions and seek reconciliation if possible. If you cannot see more than toxic then good luck. You people should leave the show for us, after all Abhinav whom you watch for is gone, so follow him please. Thank you.
Is this forum belong to you? @Deeee if it is, why don’t you just don’t approve of their posts?? Do it! Dude🤣🤣🤣🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
Wish to see your comments more often @Deee @ Surabhi.Its good to see a little balance in the comments
Who is blind is now clear after reading your comment dear. No probs. Its a matter up to you. But one tging no one here who are talking against is hating abhi character loke you guys did for abhinav. But we are just getting disappointment day by day coz that character is getting ruined. So your blindness for the actor (um sure) won’t let you see what others are implying. Again no matter. Its up to you. But how can you tell others to leave? Abhira and manyu blind fans always do this. It’s so stupid of them. You can’t say any one to leave. If you don’t like the comments and do not agree just ignore. Whether we watch or write coment or to whom we like it’s not a matter of yours. You focus on ur things and ignore others. You are not the creator of this forum nor this show to tell others to leave just because your favourite is getting bashed here. Why don’t you try pointing strong and valid reasons to justify your favourite instaed of asking others to leave or saying “oh shut up”.?
@Deeee your wish has been fulfilled since Abhinav is gone, why beg🙄🙄🙄
WE ARE STILL HERE HAPPILY POSTING DUDE🙄🙄🙄🙄 SO WHAT??? WHAT CAN YOU DO🙄🙄🙄🙄
@Deeee ok ok beg more and your wish will be fulfill when you beg till blue in the face
@Surabhi
It’s a public forum and it is individual’s choice,you sarcastically commenting and some others folding hands to begging to leave won’t work. Sorry to burst your bubbles.It is absolutely individual’s choices,some choose to stay, they will stay, some choose to quit, they will quit, some choose to extend they will extend.I repeat,it is individual’s choice.
What we should leave and let the stans take over hell no, go be cringy on X, Elon’s made it specifically for fruitcakes .
@Surabhi WE ARE STILL HERE HAPPILY COMMENTING SO WHAT?🙄🙄🙄 WHAT CAN YOU DO🙄🙄🙄🤣🤣🤣 NEHNI NEHNI POO POO😵💫😵💫
@Boo 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@Surabhi . Many people have mentioned that they’re still watching primarily to see Abhir’s reaction, which is also linked to Abhinav’s death. Additionally, numerous commenters here don’t actually watch the show; they just read updates. You come up with invalid points when you can’t support your favorite, Abhimanyu. You can’t really say anything even if they keep watching the show; it’s their decision.
Here goes again DKP muting the court arguments 🤦,we already had that sessions during custody case🙄. Now manyu boi is gonna get punished for the crime he didn’t commit!!!!I have no hopes that DKP will bring up valid question,”why exactly before 2 hours of suprise party where children are also present???”.
One day before this man was swimming in alcohol and behaved like 144P version of kabir singh, next day he bought a legal custody in Navra’s name.(though he couldn’t stop the petition of his mother’s special order),I am not gonna buy this shit in any universe. Akshara what is the purpose of your lawyer degree🙄,you thought of taking Abhir just like that without even proceeding legally, when there is special order against you??? Wahhh didi wahh didi….give your degree certificate to Abhir atleast he will play some paper boats with that.I thought all those things were taken care but they just didn’t show to the audience to focus on drama. But this is used for whitewashing this manyu.Anyways, DKP have already ordered 2-3 trucks of Birla white wash,no sense for audience expecting proper redemption from this manyu character🤦. Just waiting for Abhir to know the truth about his paapa 😢, I will be free from this shit.
@😎absolutely correct” give those degree certificates to abhir to make paper boats” 😂😂
@emoj
Agreed. That certificate better be useful at least as a toy. @Rr and @emoj, let’s see where that custody ends up. I am just frowning and disappointed. Manyu said he wanted to give it to Nav. Not Navra. I repeat, Manyu said he wanted to give it to Nav and not Navra. In other words, he wanted to give it to Abhinav and not both Abhinav and Akshara.
@Mark
That might be because by giving up custody,Manyu is loosing his right as father and placing Abhinav there but not as mother…so he choose gift Abhinav his place on his birthday(Though I knew he had no option because kid is not happy there) So that might be the reason he only wanted to gift Abhinav.
on instagram everyone is blaming akshu for accusing abhimanyu of abhinav’s death…..then do they also not remember how their god abhimanyu hurt akhsu so many times… so funny….
in the case of akhsu and abhimanyu it is very different…. even a fool knows what is right and what is wrong
Abhimanyu never sent Akshara to jail. Even with all her rudeness and unnecessary insults, he could easily have sent her to jail for paternity fraud but never did that. Abhi brought his brother’s corpse from thr hospital, saw that his twins whom he had been watching grow in the womb were gone, all those painful and traumatizing memories yet he never sent her to jail. At least she too is experiencing what it feels like to lose someone you care about in death and is already going mad. That is very good.
@Deeee Cuz he can’t. Hun I don’t think you saw the episode properly but the one who actually hit n killed Neil got jail, akshara was responsible for trying to save the girls not killing Neil. N there were witness for that n logical explanation as well. Yeah abhi was traumatized n hurt not saying he wasn’t but so was akshu the literal mother of his kids n the one carry them. On the other hand for abhimanyu unless there is proof they can’t say he didn’t kill nav cuz 1 Manish although misunderstanding saw him push nav and 2 abhimanyu was alone with abhiav at the time of delivery which automatically makes him a suspect unlike Neil’s case where they were surrounded with bad ppl.
I said he could have sent her to jail for paternity fraud but didn’t. Akshara can punish Abhi in other ways but she and her family have chosen to label him an actual murderer and jail him. I’m waiting to see what they will do when it’s shown that he is innocent. Except makers would hang Abhi for a murder he didn’t commit to please Akshnav fans.
@Deeee coz it’s NOT paternity fraud, if it was Abhi will not spared Akshu as his character n Manjiri, tell me? Why Akshu was not sent to jail? The reason is so obvious🙄
@Deeee ABHI IS STILL RESPONSIBLE EVEN THOUGH HE DID NOT KILLED ABHINAV WITH HIS HANDS
You should read up on paternity fraud Hun… Cuz u srsly Don’t know what ur talking abt n just embarrassing yourself again and again. Cuz this isn’t paternity fraud. I’ll tell u just in case anyway. Yes she hid the fact that abhir is abhimanyu’s kid but that’s not consider fraud. Paternity fraud is when the mother of a child tells the non-biological father that he is the biological father. In other words lying to her husband that the child is his when it’s not. But that’s not the case here why… Cuz Abhinav already knew abhir’s dad was someone else. There was no lying and he was not decieved.
@Sirna 👍👍👍👍👍
How can he send her to jail because she and Neil both faced this when going to save some girls. It’s not like she took Neil to a cliff for a celebration before a party and being irresponsible and careless let him fall after making him drink. Two different scenarios. But must say this ousting a wife by divorcing her even after knowing that she had a miscarriage is worst than sending to jail. Now he should feel how wrong and stupid he was to act like that. If so that is VERY GOOD. But still what we are seing is “How akshara handle these alone” a sudden care which he never had 6 yrs ago till he met akshara at kasuali.
@–
💯 Exactly….
They are so dumb like their Dumbmanyu to compare the two blames now. Like Idol,like Fans.
In Neil’s case, Police/Law were already involved,and all the girls who are saved are the witness to the scene. Akshara cannot be accused or criminal there.In Nav’s case, Manish saw in different angle and looked like pushing him. Moreover Manyu’s sudden shift of impulsive behaviour from complete alcoholic one day to Nav’s best friend next day became suspicious to everyone with sane mindset.And that’s valid doubt too. Here there is motive involved from Manyu side(Abhir rejecting to stay with Manyu).
Guys I saw on YouTube one manyu fan was arguing and couldn’t say anything to defend manyu (my guess though 😑😂) he decided to say that this is just a serial drama and we shouldn’t use logic for the plot and just enjoy the show I was like what 😭😂😂 they are gone case
@Fave
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Let’s all forget about white day, shall we, because the water has already passed that bridge. What has happened with Abhinav’s death is sui generis, worth its own space and deliberation. What happened on white day was unique, and worth its mention, but only in the attenuating circumstances. This circumstance isn’t, even remotely related to that of Neil’s death. Here Abhimanyu took Abhinav from his wife and from his son. There were options to engage Abhinav before the birthday party, (still hate surprises) but none were taken. Options existed for Akshara and for Neil where both were in their full senses. They eventually chose the course of action that led to Neil’s death. Neil was killed. Abhinav fell and died. Two different things.
Ifeel absolutely sad for akshu n abhir the pain they have to go through. I said it before n I’ll say it again u cannot deny that she doesn’t love Abhinav, he was like the world to her if not less than abhir.
And manjari n her manchild son 👏👏👏
The audacity this dude has like so shameless.. I understand that the truth is that he didn’t intentionally kill Abhinav but show some shame. Ppl are giving statements and thus dude is glaring at them , even if it wasn’t intentional it was still an accident that happened bcuz of hi he should at least show that guilt not for killing but at least for the aftermath but this dude gosh he’s beyond help. And I don’t think he’s looking at this logically like yes truth will prevail but Hun… U need evidence to prove that in a court which he doesn’t have but goenka’s do. Like it doesn’t matter if u believe kanhaji or mahadev if u Don’t have evidence or witness statement hub your as good as gone.
And majri maa… Wow the hypocrisy is coming. Before u criticize me let me tell u the difference. When Neil died it was bcuz of some goon n that dude was punished as far as I remember, ik everyone blames akshara for the impulsive decision but saving someone isn’t stupid Neil did it cuz can’t let a Prego women go alone n cuz he was abtti be the father of a girl himself. Majari still blamed her harshly n her mahan son ousted a his just wife who just miscarriaged n now she’s like don’t do the same…. Honey nothing is same like I said goons killed Neil n they got punished that’s why akshu wasn’t in jail for murder but was rather kicked out cuz they know her only fault was trying to save the girls not kill Neil.
As for abhimanyu they don’t have evidence other than words to convince akshara that abhimanyu is innocent.
And abhimanyu this man…. Goenka family has full ryt to be mad at him cuz unlike Neil where a third party was involved n killed him. Abhinav was alone with abhimanyu… In a cliff.. drunk. And Manish tho misunderstanding still saw him “push” nav… See the difference.
Istg this majari n her toxic manyu son should have been written off instead of Neil… Never like them in the first place cuz manyu was just red flag u can tell when he tried to pull a jealous card while deliberately trying to marry arohi n hit on akshara at the same time and his… I juyst don’t like emotional ppl cuz the ones around me always stir the same kind of trouble like majari does. Mother n son both need therapy.
@Sirna
I agree 💯 💯💯
Manyu had all the toxic traits since the beginning.He is a walking red flag.
@Sirna
Exactly. A red flag. I don’t know which country flag that will be?! Monaco or China?
Wow!!! How come automatically he got the custody papers envelope abruptly? He is in jail since few days and he didn’t had that envelope back then. Even his locket wasn’t there with him, his mother made him wear that then how on earth he got the envelope? I guess some sort of miracle, apart from that I don’t see any logical answer.
@Akshara
He can get instantly anything, except the petition against his mother’s special order.
@😎
😂😂😂😂😂😂 true
😂😂😂 yeah.. I too was wondering how sudden he got custody letters in his hands. He was in hospital going to operate abhinav but right then police took him and all these days he haven’t had even his locket but now he has custody pprs in his hand. Just wow.. is it a magic show..
@Akshara.
😂😂😂😂😂. The envelope would have been taken from him before he entered the lockup. But, yes they are telling the viewers that the envelope exists. This murder mystery is being worked on, is it backwards or forwards, to its inescapable conclusion.
What??? Abhimanyu when to the mountains where there are rocky slops to drink with Abhinav and give him Abhir’s custody. What nonsense Abhimanyu you don’t have to drink for that all you had to do was go was hand it to him in his hands no drinking. Who drinks on a mountain I’m not saying Abhimanyu killed Abhinav because he didn’t but come on bruh who drinks in the mountains????
@ Jade . I have been so busy. I’m just getting small time. You moron. You think you are more educated than me. Calling Nigeria as a whole, while talking to one person have shown how bad your parents taught you. You have no home training. All the platforms you comment on, this is how you swear on people. Call down evil on producers. Give actors and actresses different types of name. Go and browse and check how many illiterates Indian has. Of which I know you and your family are one . Some days ago now, you called Akshu a small harlot you even say Abhi should be killed. Did I query you. Honestly, they way you talk, it has shown people that you are an ill-bred. A tout.
@Funmi.
Permit me to apologise, for the language used as to your nationality. I didn’t post for some few episodes your comment drew my attention here. Sorry once again. Now the rest is between you both. But, please don’t bring the parents into it. They are the elders.
Yes. This is not her first time she dragged parents and insult. And if the other is having a misunderstanding on nationality she could have reject those and clear the misunderstandings. If the other is wrong could have correct her/him without dragging elders. For the sake of arguing why both parties fall to a cheap level?
@Funmi, I am South African that’s the first point. My point is STILL true Nigeria has backwards ideology and that shows in your thinking with “Akshara must prove herself “pure” before she is accepted” it’s the same ideology from a country which discriminates against women. You’re not as clever as you assume if you don’t understand a simple thing called context, cause you clearly have zero understanding of what those comments you mentioned were about. Anyway I’m done with you, disappear. 🫰
For me i think it’s not only beyond redemption of Manyu character but also i don’t feel abhira compatible for each other as husband and wife. I started to watch this show because of Harshali as i had been watched their previous show Bepanah and Barrister Babu. However, once i started to watch this show and immediately i felt it’s not my cup of tea due to the cringe romance they portrayed and frequently showing ML six abs. I start watched it because of Abhinav character as it feel refreshing. If the writer can written such a beautiful character of Abhinav which was not a ML then why they can’t do the same for manyu’s character. Its like pain in ass to watch this character including his mother’s character. The writer written well on how a normal and simple middle class yet beautiful household can be by showing us the relationships between Akshnavir. It’s like a treat to the eyes. The mess up is cause by the writer, director and the producer not even the actor themselves and we can’t blame the audience too when they bashing the characters.
@Riz.
I agree. The characters especially that of Abhimanyu could have been written in a different way. His anger and impulsiveness built in so that there is some scope for conflict. The Sharmas used to have arguments as well. But the Abhira arguments always looked polarising and tough to watch. The stubbornness of the Akshara character didn’t match the resolution of the Abhimanyu character. This imbalance between the two of them is what led to the leap, after falling TRP ratings.
@Francis i agree with you. The makers already succeed for the previous 2 generations so they should already know what kind of relationship they want to portray rather than just messed it up to core that we as audience can’t think another reunion of Abhira. Yes even Sharma’s has their arguments and flaws too but they solve and face it with understanding, respect, communicate with each other and as well be each other strength. Manyu with his implusive behavior and Ak with her stubbornness will always lead to their suffering. Plus the track when Manyu confessed his love to Ak and expect her to run away with him leave behind Nav and abhir was so shameless and never thought that makers can ruin their ML character’s this way.
@Riz.
True. The makers could have tried to improve Akshara to match up the towering Abhimanyu. Like a power couple. Or would have let him marry Aarohi who can go shoulder to shoulder with him. But making him impeccable and making Akshara vulnerable isn’t a nice way to pair the characters. The Abhimanyu character is not so bad but when viewers in the same serial can compare an Abhinav, for example, they start to see where he is falling short. The makers are just muddling this character further with the controversies surrounding him. When Abhinav came in we can see his shortcomings and the fans can appreciate it. I think Abhimanyu, when the neutrals want to like him, then he gets involved in a grey area decision where they are asking, what are his motives? For example, he knew that Akshara loved Abhinav but he kept mum, while his mum was pushing for a reunion.
@Francis
Exactly. Manyu knew before hand that Akshara was in love with Nav. But he kept mum when Goenkas faced Manjiri. He could have shown his strong objection then and there. But he was shamelessly leading his mom on.
@Francis@Riz@Mark All of you are absolutely right.Its a family based show ,one expects ML to have flaws but you cannot compromise with basic human decency and values. which is what they have done with Abhimanyu s character.Whatever he does just does not click as he’s the good guy.Look at foreign shows even crime based Bones,911 white collar,psyches,House MD one is rooting for the flawed ML but look at Abhimanyu today he’s glaring at Muskaan,Kairav damn it Abhinav was her brother same as Neil was to you…You were gifting Abhinav what guardianship or custody? You have no authority to give “custody” court will decide or is now court your pocket? Abhimanyu you have fallen so low
Just a thought I would like to watch new show with harshad and Ayesha Singh as leads in mature love story. I am tired of watching him play angry young man with tragic past roles so may be he can be happy go lucky cheerful character
As much as i hate toxicmanyu’s character I also like HC and would vouch for your idea of an actually creative team of professional show makers casting HC and AS as main leads of a story. Who knows in future we might see them sharing screen together but the problem is there are no mature team of writers so we are subjected to nonsense shows. Pakistani shows are much better where atleast it ends unlike this show who’s legacy has been destroyed after the end of first gen yet it has been going on and on and on and now its 14 years. I was a school kid when this show started and now I’m in my 20’s
@Ashle I so want to see Ayesha with Jay though 😭😭😭 Harshad looks AMAZING with Jenny, I really really want to see the 2 of them paired up on screen again.
The custody handover 🤦♀️ I knew the makers would use this so-called sacrifice act by Abhimanyu to whitewash him. After a week of repeated mistakes by the Birlas, Navra would have won the custody battle so easily. So it doesn’t matter if Abhimanyu gives custody back to Navra after being cornered by his own son. If Abhimanyu had decided on shared custody on the day of winning custody, I would have truly felt he was changing for the better. After all that Manjiri did and his silent support for his mother’s action, this handing back of custody doesn’t matter. The markers ruin this redemption arc for Abhimanyu. We as viewers know that Abhimanyu didn’t kill, but the questions of viewers about why Abhimanyu presented the idea of drinking alcohol before partying and that 2 at the cliff and without Kairav are valid questions, and holding Abhimanyu responsible for Abhinav’s death is also not wrong. He doesn’t have an ounce of guilt over what happened. He has accepted from Akshara to say sorry to his mother for Neil’s death but has not seen him be guilty have what happened to Abhinav. The way he was looking at Kairav and Muskaan felt like he was saying Yes, I killed you, but you can’t harm me”. Arre makers please don’t use this blame game as redemption arc it’s not working at all infact making Abhimanyu more unlikable to viewers who didn’t liked him before as it seems whitewash and not redemption.
And Manjiri saying, You don’t do what I did, was like saying only I can make mistakes and punish people wrongly and no one else.
@Ara
You just wrote what I felt. We want his redemption, not whitewashing.
I agree I’ve seen his previous shows honestly the cast is talented but the character given to them by the writer….like God it’d be easier to read murder documentary than go through with each character especially birla house …. I can’t tell what they do to raise kids Neel n parth were nice but they flipped party’s character to be garbage n aniha wasn’t any nice literally threatening u with suicide , emotional blackmail, while going around cheating on her soon to be husband. Abhimanyu wasn’t any less sometimes I consider him worse than his dad but sometimes m like the last worse thing he didn’t do is cheat on her. But all in all the writers conveyed that in birla house u will inherit not only intelligence but also the knowledge to emotional blackmail ppl n to also pass on the abusive knowledge to the children.
@Sirna well said👍
@Ara.
I concur. Abhimanyu is unable to step away from the controversy. His motives are not so clear. He could have called out Akshara later so that he seals with both of them. Together. Now, doing so is another question. He is now all about the questions. He will have to answer those.
That is to seal the deal with both Akshara and Abhinav. But, he instinctively shies away from working with the Sharma couple together.
@Francis
Though you are right that Manyu didn’t consider working together with sharma couple in the past like Parents Teacher meeting, Abhir’s school assignment what to become in future.These was only decided by AK and Manyu without considering Abhinav.
But when it comes to gifting custody to Abhinav only because Manyu is gifting father rights to Abhinav by giving up the custody case.Ak rights can never be given to other person (though Manjari
restricted) ….only Abhinav’s rights were replaced by Abhimanyu legally.
@😎.
Yes. Noted. Abhimanyu is trying to give Abhinav back what was his in the first place. Nice gesture. Good intentions. Grandiose occassion. Happy birthday. Then what went wrong? I have questions. He, Abhimanyu, has to help me understand how this event happened. He didn’t kill Abhinav, but he put Abhinav in harm’s way, isn’t it?
@Francis
I agree that Abhimanyu is still answerable to the question “why getting drunk exactly before the birthday party?”. I am assuming that makers are gonna skip that by muting the arguments. We as audience will still have that question.
@😎.
True. Though I don’t expect much now from the makers. I hope they do more here.
@Ara
Exactly “You don’t do what I did, was like saying only I can make mistakes and punish people wrongly and no one else” Agreed.
When Abhir got bad dream that his paapa left,he got so tensed,promised to be good boy and requested to never leave him. Donno tomorrow when Abhir will know the truth😨 left him forever. Another emotional rollercoaster ride. Uuuuffff……
@😎.
So many missed clues about the imminence of Abhinav’s death. I can see that Abhir would be heartbroken, though I can also fear for his beating heart.
@😎 there were so many signs from the universe for the Sharma’s to not leave Kasauli
@😎 IKR! That was the initial thought that crossed my mind when Abhir began asking for his dad. It’s heartbreaking to see this young child, who recently underwent a major heart surgery, facing such turmoil in his life. After the surgery, he discovered that Abhinav isn’t his biological father, Akshara-Abhinav broke his heart, had to leave his parents’ home to live at Birla House, and just as he finally got what he wanted, he lost his pappa. He always wished to live in Kasauli with his small, happy family, but now his dream is about to be shattered in the coming days. It’s likely they won’t allow him to go to Kasauli at all now.
@Sara
That is my worst fear. Not getting the chance to return to Kasauli
The flower, which fell from Abhinav’s hands after his prayer in Kasauli, was laid on his corpse in the Birla hospital in Udaipur, very symbolically…Stood waiting for this epic moment for so many episodes! Bravo creators, slowly but surely history goes in its turn))…
The dogs bark, but the caravan goes on!
Yes.Dogs bark, but the caravan goes on!The dog is you and your Dogman.
Everyone thinks according to their ignorance!
Exactly like you.
Sure!