Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai 22nd April 2023 Written Episode, Written Update on TellyUpdates.com
Akshara refuses to give the file. She says to Abhimanyu that he isn’t Abhir’s doctor thus he doesn’t have right on his son. Abhimanyu says along with doctor he is Abhir’s father. He questions Akshara about hiding truth despite knowing his relationship with Harshvardhan. Abhimanyu asks Akshara why she didn’t told about Abhir. He says he amid the two twins one survived. Abhimanyu says he was going through an uncalled attachment with Abhir and was surviving alone thinking why he feels connection with him. He accuses Akshara for hiding Abhir’s truth from him. Abhimanyu confront Akshara about snatching his right on Abhir. He accuses Akshara avenging on him by hiding Abhir.
Abhimanyu cries thinking he is unlucky to cherish son-father relationship. He accuses Akshara for taking away Abhir despite knowing the truth. Abhimanyu asks Akshara if she for once didn’t thought about revealing Abhir’s truth to him despite knowing his childhood trauma. Akshara says to Abhimanyu that she don’t have any reason to tell the truth. Abhimanyu stands stunned. Akshara says she never wanted to reveal the truth to him since he learned is he has courage to learn the truth. She adds she will spill the truth but will he be able to hear the truth. Abhimanyu asks Akshara to speak up.
Akshara says Abhir is Abhimanyu’s son but he can’t be his father. Abhimanyu asks the reason. Akshara says being a father is a long journey and he failed. She adds that day she lost everything too than how his pain got greater than her. Akshara questions Abhimanyu about accusing her for Neil and their baby’s death. She tells to Abhimanyu that he don’t have a right to learn the truth. Akshara tells to Abhimanyu that she called him number of times but he ignored her and breaks his relationship with her. She says she wanted Abhimanyu in her pregnancy journey but he was not with her.
Akshara reveals to Abhimanyu how Abhinav helped her and Abhir during their crucial time. She tells to Abhimanyu that only Abhinav has a right to be called as Abhir’s father. Akshara says she has given Abhinav all the right to become Abhir’s father. She says to Abhimanyu that she won’t let him become Abhir’s father ever. Akshara takes away the file from Abhimanyu.
Abhimanyu says to Akshara that she is right still she can’t take away his right on Abhir. Akshara tells to Abhimanyu that she has taken the decision to take Abhir and Abhinav to US and it is unchanged. Abhimanyu think he was clueless about Abhir and now Akshara is snatching the right from him. He imagines Abhir everywhere and breaks down. [Episode Ends]
Precap: Abhimanyu challenges Akshara that he won’t let her take Abhir to US. Akshara stands stunned.
95 Comments
You have to give it to the cast and crew for giving this confrontation it’s own episode. Top notch, in my opinion well executed and the leads nailed every bit of the anger, anguish and anxiety, all of those and how reading this I am going through the emotions. Thinking about what the parents of Abhir went through on their seperate journeys. Abhimanyu felt betrayed and now he knows what happened he lost the argument, as I had predicted. The logic behind Akshara was unassailable and this outcome was never in doubt. It went exactly as I said it would. Abhimanyu is a fighter and now that he knows he wouldn’t give up so easily. And this is to be expected given what is known about the character.
Akshara felt vindicated by her explanation and had a momentary victory. She now has to persist and look for a way to avoid a drawn out conflict over Abhir, as this would wear down everybody and weaken Abhinav’s resolve to be with her, which I think that she wants.
This is the second one in the confrontation series. I believe that there will be one more to settle the question of whether Abhir wants to be with Akshara or Abhimanyu. Or maybe not.
@Francis. True both actors have performed well. Each an every emotion was perfectly portrayed by them. 👌
But now with the precap looks like there going to be a fight or struggle between them and i think they both have not told any thing on this to arohi and abhinav. Will this struggle affect abhir’s health what will happen to abhir abhinav arohi n ruhi..😱😨😨😨
@Pz.
I don’t think Akshara has told Abhinav about Abhimanyu as she would ‘assume’ based on previous interaction that it would upset Abhinav. She should have confided in him so their reactions to the precap don’t diverge. I think that Abhimanyu hasn’t told Aarohi about this, I feel that he might open up if she insists although he might ‘assume’ again that there is an awkward relationship between the sisters and he’d better not say anything. So some factors not outlined are mitigating the actions of the two. Over time this may affect Aarohi and Ruhi more as Abhimanyu will probably try to hide his pain and in this fail to communicate with his new family. As the Navra relationship has further mileage, Akshara might find a way to inform Abhinav soon.
as I said yesterday it is also a personal revenge that Akshara has inflicted on Abhimanyu. Because even though her story is hard she hasn’t really tried to warn Abhimanyu until now, Akshara talks about how much Abhimanyu put her pain before her, but she doesn’t talk about how she continues to feel like a victim and does not admit any involvement with the accident. Abhimanyu is right even though she feels she suffered, she had no right to judge whether or not Abhimanyu deserved to be Abhir’s father. Akshara has proven today that she could have warned Abhimanyu but she returned Abhimanyu’s paternity as some kind of punishment for him as she thinks she is the only one wronged. Anything that said Akshara and staying away because she felt guilty understood that Akshara just wanted to hide the truth. After the day of the accident she made two calls to him but she never contacted him personally after. Akshara has always helped by her desire to save several people esque she gave them rights over her?. At the time what Abhinav did and an act of enormous good faith, but no one gives his parental rights to the Nurse who takes care of the babies after a mother and makes a difficult delivery, the nurses constantly have to watch the children and rocking them, she also provides them with medical care, yet no one will give them parental rights. Some women go through their pregnancy alone with the help of a friend, yet she does not give their rights, Akshara will never see the consequences of her mistakes. At the next confrontation, Abhimanyu might also tell Akshara that she put her resentment above all else and that she too did not try to understand his point of view, and that her own ego alienated her from her son. Akshara Abhimanyu’s justifications accepted them. But will Akshara accept Abhimanyu’s? I don’t think so because Akshara can’t see the harm she can do to others because she thinks she is filled with good intentions.
@Yoel
If the thoughts I am discussing with you do not satisfy you, I hope you will not be upset or angry.
1. You say Akshu is taking revenge on Abhi, It’s wrong. Akshu used her own son against Abhi? If it was true that she took revenge, she would not give the letter Abhi wrote to Abher and read it to him. And Akshu also told Abhinav that Abhi and Abher are connected from the heart anyway. And Akshu has also confirmed that Abhi is still Abher’s father, but will not be empowered. That’s right.
2. Even if you give 1001 Akshu wrongs, there will be 1002 Abhi mistakes, and you won’t be able to go back in time 6 years ago so that those things didn’t happen. Akshu told Abhi about his journey after being abandoned by Abhi, leaving Birla’s house, knowing that she was pregnant until her birth, Abhi had to torment himself, this is the basic point that Akshu does not forgive for Abhi, Abhi himself did not say a word. Now is the way to deal with its consequences, if there is no positive thought and action, it will lead to many consequences later, especially 2 children. Abher and Ruhi.
3. You are happier than Akshu because beside you, you also have a husband and families to share and encourage. But Akshu was alone with a complete stranger. But her faith is in place, proving to you it’s been her life for the past 6 years with Abhinav’s care for Abher, Akshu.
4. Akshu gives Abhinav paternity, because it was Abhinav who revived Abher and Akshu. Without Abhinav, she and her son would have died. So is this wrong? Abhi left Akshu when she needed her husband the most, a stranger, with a normal life, reaching out to help, without asking for anything in return. Akshu’s life was at a standstill, with Abhinav’s help without any conditions, in this life it was very difficult to meet such a person.
In my life I have faced several storms on my own, I do not understand Akshara’s behavior, I have never been too irresponsible so I easily admit my mistakes. Akshara is not like women who are financially deprived, Akshara could have done better, she could have stayed with her friend and continued a peaceful pregnancy, Akshara had relatives and we have the right to claim their support. Abhinav helped Akshara but the doctors helped Akshara they were the ones who put Abhir through painstaking labor to life, they were the ones who really saved the lives of mother and son by minimizing the risks, when the statistics are bass only a miracle can brighten life. Abhinav taking Akshara to hospital helped Akshara but he could have called an ambulance. If a baby is destined not to live despite all the care in the world, he will not live, I know that. Abhinav deserves Abhir but not that way we don’t give parental rights out of gratitude because it means all the doctors and people we were there for us also deserve rights (my brother-in-law and sister-in-law were for me throughout my pregnancies and I’m so thankful for that). If she fell in love with him, and they got married and Abhir was recognized as Abhinav Sharma’s son afterwards, it would have been fairer and more beautiful. Abhinav is a man who has earned a place of hero in Akshara’s life but Akshara was not a financially destitute woman friendly alone or even on the family side, she has paternal and maternal grandparents, she had a wide range of choices but she risked her life going wandering on the road. @Fave Akshara has been living in anger against Abhimanyu for 6 years, it was shown from the beginning of this track. I know single women who gave birth alone, others who had ivf and my own sister-in-law who gave birth and raised a baby alone, all of her wives have been through things that even I would never have imagined. far from theirs yet they have not made the choices of Akshara, the world is meanand they are careful especially with their child, we never fully know a person 9 months or even ten years later we could learn or discover unsuspected facts about a person. Look at Shefali, she thought she knew Parth, she built a family with him and look at the result. Humans don’t always appear to be what they appear to be, and one day someone wakes up and sees strangers in front of them they don’t know. I hope for Akshara that she never has to regret her choice
@@yeol every second counts in this type of situations!!! How can u judge Abhinav not calling ambulance???
Frustration for favorite Abhimanyu behaving like a cannibal. He does not deserve abhir
Exactly! Comparing Abhinav to nurses or helpers is Absurb! I dun hve to explain coz the reason for not giving the nurses or any helpers that help with delivery n taking care of babies the parental rights are obvious n common sense!!
Get break why you always find ways to blame akshara in every episode like she said both fatherhood and motherhood is not a journey of one day she had 9months to see and experience how a good father abhinav can be plus what he did for during labor was enough for her to judge whether he could be a good father or not and he is right today’s episode was on point you don’t have to bring up your imagination every time is it a sane thing for someone to keep dwelling in the past for 6years
Totally agreed @Fave I just dun understand her mindset, every situation is different, every person’s thinking is different!! Dwelling on the past dun help the present situation, why keep re- living the past, if the past is giving pain???
@@yeol.
I know that we’re not on the same page on the evolution of the characters in this serial and we don’t have to be. But then I think here that you be tactical enough to show flexibility on the points mooted. There’s no harm in doing so. Again I apologise if I seem to cross the line, I think prior comments should have made an impression on your respected viewpoint. Sticking to your guns like this makes you look inconsistent when you blame Akshara for the same. Your views are rich and I think I now see the logic in some of them. Again this is a fictional story and the resemblance to real life is coincidental and not meant to bring strife to us commenters.
Looking at Akshara I supported the journey of her character and I now want to know more about Abhimanyu’s character to have an enriched viewing or following of the story and the post-leap story is the rave of the country as of now. You know that Akshara and Abhinav got married before Abhir’s birth but you choose to refer to him as a nurse which is disrespectful. But let’s leave these things as they are. Let’s say someone refers to you as a nurse in a writing, will you take it on the chin and get on with it. I’ll let you be the judge of that.
If grateful people are giving nurses n helpers their parental rights I wonder how many children will these nurses n helpers have!!! smh😵💫😵💫
Which nurses and helpers stay beside you in the total period of pregnancy? Nurses and doctors do their work because they are paid for it. Abhinav extended his effort,trust and care to Akshara without expecting anything in return. He didnt step back even when he faced the extreme situations. Thats something which people in our very close circles do like our mother,father, husband. So your comparison between Abhinav and nurse is totally absurd.
Abhinav didn’t just appear on the night Abhir was born and look after him… he was at Akshara’s side for a good few months looking after both Akshara and Abhir even though he was still in her womb. They formed a friendly bond over several months. Y’all keep downplaying Abhinav, is it cause he’s poor and not affluent like the Birla’s. Abhinav was Akshara’s well wisher then her friend, he didn’t fall from Jupiter during the storm, he was a known precious friend not a stranger. Akshara saw his dedication and the people of the village already assumed them married so they signed papers to make it legal… l am not a fan of Akshara or Abhimanyu, I’ve always found them cringey and annoying but Akshara at that point probably felt abandoned and traumatised not that she’s a great character but time passes by fast, maybe she didn’t want to tell Abhimanyu as Abhir and Abhinav had already bonded and they love each other a lot, when Abhimanyu met Abhir in hospital Abhir even told him to save him mostly for his papa cause he can’t sleep without him, maybe her reasoning was to prevent her son and husband from being hurt and also preventing Abhir’s life from being split between 2 parents and the toxicity between them… right now though they both are wrong, Abhir’s health and recovery should come first.
@Jade.
The TRP ratings show the uptick in the story. Viewers aren’t always looking for romance although that is a welcome distraction sometimes. They want to see genuine friendship, goodwill and harmony. That’s where Abhinav comes in. Many viewers won’t respect Abhinav and what he has done because they see him as poor just as you wrote. He has won Akshara’s heart with little resources and his own good nature. She is a bit intransigent here but this is coming out from a place that Abhinav shouldn’t be hurt in any way over Abhir. I hope that Abhimanyu sees the facts and doesn’t unintentionally destroy this family.
Exactly @Francis n @Jade, subconsciously she/he judges Abhinav coz Abhinav cannot provided Akshara n Abhir the lifestyle Goenkas n Abhimanyu can give Abhir!! Else why insist to judge Akshara not going to Goenkas?? To Akshara happiness is love n respect n peace!!
@yeol i have read about your story before. But didn’t want to comment on your pov about akshu because of a reason. But now i like to say this but sorry if i hurt to and trust i don’t want to hurt you. You know that goenka family always favour only one girl in a tough time when they both need family. During Neil’s death they mainly focused on arohi and no one knew akshu left. So hiw can she stay peacefully when goenka have to face birla everytime and facing all accusations. So she left but not to abhinav but to her friend. When manish came there she got hurt again hearing what he was saying and it made her think that she might be a burden for them. And i think it happens. So i don’t thonk akshu not going back to goenka house is a wrong decision. And fortunately she met a hood guy and i think it was because of her good nature. And she called her several times to tell abhi the good news. But she was not lucky enough fir that to hear a good reply from the other side infact she was broken down again. But with yiur story u were lucky enough that you had supportive relations unlike goenkas n u were lucky enough that you didn’t hear what abhi yokd akshu from your husbnd. Because i think any person if hear such harsh words will break in to pieces and it is really painful. With that pain and seing abhinav’s sacrifices she decided that abhinv is the best for abhir. She choose nav for few reasons 1. She didn’t want to go back in to abhis life 2. She wanted her son to live without being joked by society 3. She witnesed nav is best n etc. Doctors n nurse do their duty n abhinav did a sacrifise n appreciable job. So asking doc or nurse to be father and nav being father are two different things. Its like an insult. So i don’t see wrong in that decision also. But she was clear on one thing that although she hide truth she will not snatch their bond. Otherwise she shouldhave not given letter n tgat pair of football shoes. She is ok if thry stay closer but not knowing the truth bcz she knew hiw birkas are n she thiught tgat they will take abhir from her. And about nav u were telling that he was overreacting or sth like that during akshus delivery time. He could have calked ambulance n so on. But wanna tell one thing i have seen in news that on a heavy rainy day a husbnd had to carry his preg wife to the hospital bcz ambulances couldn’t come due to flood. He went by foot carring his wife n i see this incident as such thing so i dont see it as overdrama. And nav’s caring on abhir either. Othr ting is you say akshu only ralk about her pain not abhi’s but i think it is the other way. She was asking why tgey thought about thier pain n not hers. Actualy she was going through both physical n mental pain whike others had only mental pain. They never gave any chance to akshu to soeak n scold put the bkame directly without hearing what happened. She was really sorry for the deaths but she was never given a chance even to see neil. I have no doubts on abhis parenting but he lost that chance by himself.
@Pz Why did she only care about her pain, why she still thinks they think about her pain more than hers when she doesn’t think about their pain either. Akshara’s pregnancy was in an embryonic state, and in this state a miscarriage has no physical repercussions very rarely there is an infection it’s more mental the pain of the loss but Can this kind of pain really be compared to losing a son you raised who you gave milk to and changed diapers? Of course not. Akshara was going through psychological pain just like Abhimanyu and Abhimanyu’s loss was greater than his own. If she was sorry, she would have expressed it as Abhimanyu expressed it. Akshara never apologized once and never admitted her mistake. Akshara continues to put her personal feelings above all else. How is that an insult the doctors are also doing an appreciable job they are sacrificing their time and sleep to save lives it is a choice just like Abhinav made his choice, and is it his justice to give him rights? of course not, recognition does not justify this choice. Abhinav could have called an ambulance or medical help to advise him in rainy and stormy weather, anything can happen outside, it was an unnecessary risk, it would have been better if she had started pre-delivery work at home with him with the help of a vocal medical assistant until the ambulance arrives. You say she don’t want to tear their bond, but whenever Abhimanyu and too close, she reminds him that he is not Abhir’s father, she prefers to live far away to limit their closeness she doesn’t want neither does Abhimanyu and any kind of right on Abhir. to keep her secret she was willing to do anything, hide the truth and taunt Abhimanyu and a way to snatch their bond from them. Akshara did bad things Manish said things that hurt her but that doesn’t justify her running away, she still had friends and family on both sides, a brother who would have been there for her and would protect her secret. Akshara never thinks before acting, had she not met Abhinav her impulsiveness would have cost her her life.
I rest my case in putting sense !! Well a life is still a life whether is of an unborn child or adult child!!
it’s true but does not relegate the intensity of the loss to the same level, the baby she lost was not even considered medically viable, medically speaking he was not yet considered a human. when your child becomes a fetus that you can feel him growing inside you and you give birth to him when he will stop living I fully understand the depth of the pain felt, you may not have shared memories but you know his face and his smell it’s heartbreaking so I dare not imagine the pain of losing an adult child, but I understand a little because I knew a brother who grew up by my side and who left. So don’t compare the incomparable.
Why the intensity of the loss of her Son was only shown towards Akshara? If Manjari and Abhi was so considerate and sincere to Neil, why they like the idea of replacing Neil’s place with Abhi in Ruhi’s life. Why they dont want to keep even Neil’s name alive. Today Ruhi talked about writing Ruhi Abhimanyu Birla in her Book. Why Arohi and Abhimanyu didnt even have the flash of Neil’s memory there? I dont think Neil anymore matter to them. You are talking about the intensity of loss which even they do not feel? Birlas do not have any problem to snatch the rights of Neil even to remain in memories of his daughter, but they still hate Akshara. Ridiculous!!
Ok.. um not downgrading doctors n nurse job. But what you said is🤔🙄😏
6 yrs has gone but yet tgey all blame her. Yes pain is there always with our loved one’s decease. And we do remember them always. But how can we find our peace by puting the blame on some other who has not killed that deceased. Akshu had no intension to kill neil but still they think she killed neil n babies. Think what pain she is going through till now for a blame of killing neil n babies n it has not over yet. Why we make another person’s life who is alive darker for a person who is not among us that too when they have no complete involvement 🤔🤔🤔 She is not thinking about her self infact asking why tgey do so bcz she knows every one had a loss
@Pz Akshara didn’t live a dark life she had her son and Abhinav but yet she also makes Abhimanyu’s life dark by holding a grudge against him when as you say she is partly responsible. She lived 6 years without receiving any blame from anything, Manjiri accuses her but even Abhimanyu didn’t accuse her after the jump. Asking for forgiveness today would have cost him what, the intention was not bad but is it apologizing that a life was lost. I have known some good people like Abhinav in my life and they are still friends, but should I have married them out of gratitude, what nonsense. I married a man who did not have the same financial level as me I supported her and now he has succeeded and treats me extremely well despite some arguments, esque I should have married other people I have known since longer because they supported me, of course not I married for love, it would never have been fair if I had put myself with someone with the idea that one day I would end up loving them because he helped me 🤦what an injustice. I emphasize Akshara’s behavior because everyone considers her choices justified despite the consequences because she had good intentions. and Akshara did she find peace in consideration during all her years as Abhimanyu and only responsible for this situation, she held a grudge for 6 years.
Every one asked her to leave from their lives, the people she considered her loved ones. If she stayed at goenka then every day she is getting blamed. Is it right? So isn’t it an injustice? Isn’t it enough for her to question? What pz said is right. Birlas are making akshu’s life like a living hell blaming for Neil’s and babies death.
@true! Akshara sense of victim hood is massive. She has lectured Abhimanyu on his failings and is completely oblivious of her own shortcomings.
Confrontation was actually good. Akshu spoke her heart out. Her trauma, fears & his mistakes that made him loose abhir. And abt abhi, he behaved exactly how I wanted. Yelled at first, but later accepted the truth & now is ready to fight for abhir without turning a villain
I am just so heartbroken by the fact that his pain has always been sidelined- he too lost his everything that day, he lost freaking 6 years of his child’s life- he’s been suffering the most since that day but I guess I expected way too much- his trauma will never get addressed.
as much as people would like to ignore this, they showed the condition abhi was in, when she called. his mother was having attacks one after the other, akshara being her triggering point. how is he supposed to act sane on the call? why is this not addressed did she even know she was triggering point of manjari and their was a threat for manjari life …it’s as if she hd selective amnesia abt wht happened at his home.a physical death&two unborn babies.if he decided nt 2 take her calls as a time out frm Ak to her going to mayka 4 evry fight dey hd he is correct
She shld hv waited & tried harder not blame
I love the part where abhi didn’t play any victim card for his mistakes and he really felt guilty for what he did, at the same tym, he is not ready to give up his rights..
The reason why AbhimanyuBirla will always remain superior bec he owns up his mistakes like a king.Even today when AK blamed that he did not lift her calls,he agreed & said that she was right in her place but he did it deserve that treatment
@Jazz how about Abhinav’s call?? What he told Abhinav? He wanted nothing to do with Akshara n her baby!
I agree with you Jazz. Abhimanyu was a victim many times in the past. His only problem is anger and impulsiveness, and not trusting or respecting Akshu. There is still hope for him. Oddly enough, Akshara had always been able to manage angry Abhi and impulsive Abhi but disrespectful and not trusting Abhi, not so much. Its good today he did not mention his situation at the time as there is time for that later.
NB: Akshu does not know the state Manjiri was in. If she comes to know, i think this will be the only door that can let in Abhira back.
As i said in the past, Manjiri and Abhi did not give a chance to Akshu to show them how sorry she is. They ousted her from their sight and life and thus missed the chance to see their enemy (Akshu) in pain and suffering. And Akshu, stayed away as she wanted to have a talk with herself e.t.c. She told this to manish.
As I said Akshara’s personality is going to make the whole process difficult, and as I predicted Abhimanyu was not going to give up his rights quietly, as he considers Akshara did him an injustice and wants to continue. He understands the difficulties and the pain of Akshara he even accepts them, but he does not manage to accept that for personal reasons she has removed Abhir from his life. The confrontation between Birla and Goenka can’t be avoided, now everyone will use their arguments if Akshara won’t be reasonable to settle the matter calmly. Akshara whether she likes it or not she has committed legal harm against Abhimanyu and as she studies law she knows about it. so I don’t understand why she isn’t looking for a friendly solution. Goenka will have to wake up and defend Akshara’s rights by supporting her. They can judge Akshara’s choice but above all they should be on the side of the family in this kind of situation. Abhimanyu this time will be within his rights to demand a legal confrontation if Akshara doesn’t seek a quiet solution. I also just realized that Akshara has a lot of resentment for Abhimanyu, but Abhimanyu on the contrary he didn’t really hold any resentment for Akshara even though she has some responsibility in Niel’s affair. Abhimanyu just feels broken because he was separated from his son, I’m really impressed with him today because he didn’t deny any of his mistakes on the contrary he accepted them.
@Ariya
Akshu tells Abhi that he can find out the truth about Neil’s accident and death, as well as learn about her and Abher’s life during the years apart. But he didn’t, Is this called love?
I think it’s Akshu’s anger towards Abhi, not resentment. Furthermore, Akshu knew very well that Abhi would never be able to decide for his own future. Abhi’s life revolves around Manjari, Manjari’s aversion to Akshu is irreconcilable. If Abher’s truth is revealed, there will be more trouble for her little family.
Abhi and Akshu will have to calmly deal with this, respectfully, and put Abher’s health and well-being first.
@Flower I would never consider Abhimanyu’s relationship with Akshara as love. What I see between Akshara and Abhinav is love because there is respect. Akshara and angry but also resentful, she resents Abhimanyu for making cowardly decisions back then and she suffered from it. But I recognize that Abhimanyu my surprise he didn’t deny his mistakes, and even though he too suffered he didn’t put his pain from that time in front of Akshara, he didn’t try to justify his mistakes and he respects the pain that Akshara has suffered through his fault. For me to see Abhimanyu’s change shows that Abhimanyu is not such a bad person, and for the sake of Abhir Akshara should understand that legal involvement might be hardship for his son. She should kinda think about finding a friendly solution, I hope to see a positive development from her tomorrow, I know Akshara can be stubborn but she can also be sweet and understanding, Akshara has family fiber and in my job I know it’s rare, always looking for the well-being of our family is a rather rare thing. Akshara should also look at the legal side since she started studying law, Akshara has matured but I hope to see greater maturity on her part by thinking first about the legal aspect and then adopting an attitude that will be beneficial. I hope she is not intransigent without having a plan or a solid case because she will be the only one to suffer a loss because it is no longer about Akshara and Abhimanyu but about a father and a mother who will try to keep their rights but who also think about the health of their child
I dont think Akshara would loss this battle. Even if Abhi wins the legal custody, he would most probably fail in front of his son. Abhir would not be ready to give up both Akshara and Abhinav from his life. It is now Akshara’s turn to express her feelings. Everyone had blamed her enough and punished her more than enough for the mistakes that accidentally happened by her.Now, let others hear her out. I dont want her to be submissive in front of Birlas this time.
Abhir loves both his parents too much to succeed in accepting Abhimanyu if by his fault he is separated from them. a child’s world revolves around his parents and even though Abhir appreciates Abhimanyu, it will never be on the same level as his father and mother.
@Ariya
Abhi realizes his mistake because Abhi was told by Dr Sandeep the story of a miracle boy, born on a stormy night, overcoming death through the sacrifice of a person for whom Abhi must be grateful. Thanks to that person, he had the opportunity to stand up for Abher’s fatherhood. And Abhi himself knows very well Akshu’s complications during pregnancy and possible loss of her life. Regret was in Abhi’s eyes so he was speechless. If Abhi competes for custody of Abher, it is unethical, but if he knows how to put his ego down, knows how to use soft ways to convince Akshu, has love and reason, ensures Abher’s interests, I think Akshu will understand and agree. As it is no longer a story of two people, but of two families, many people will be affected.
And this is also the time when Abhi should decide to end his and Arohi’s marriage.
@Flower Akshara has a rather loving nature if she managed to open up and listened to Abhimanyu or if the two of them had a heart to heart conversation and she gave Abhimanyu a chance to convince her Akshara might very well reconsider. Akshara felt hurt a lot by Abhimanyu as she loved him deeply so she is not going to be easily convinced by him.
@Ariya; @Flower.
I think that Akshara is both angry and resentful of Abhimanyu. She underwent a heartbreak along with the loss of one of the babies and her lovely brother-in-law. However the events leading to the loss of Neil’s life, is a tragedy the Birlas are facing today. Although I have to sympathise over that loss as Neil is never coming back to life. Abhimanyu was overwhelmed by the circumstances and meted out a punishment that led all the way to the events of the present day.
I now sympathise with him as well. He had overreacted and now he has lost the love of his life. I wonder how he keeps a brave face. One underlying feature of the story is that Abhimanyu had to listen keenly to the story of how he was replaced in Akshara’s life by Abhinav. As Akshara was rehashing the details, I was enmeshed in sympathy for Abhimanyu as Akshara was talking about the state of their relationship as a fait-accompli. She wasn’t thinking of going back so maybe resentment isn’t the state of play here. Antipathy then? Maybe. She hates him such that she would rather not have anything to do with him. She is practically erasing his memories from her life. This then looks excessive to me, but it is consistent with what I think I know about the character. She goes all in when she forms her relationships or she goes out of them cleanly.
Abhimanyu will fight for a place in Abhir’s life and I really like if he remembers the past love and not go blow for blow in this regard as the heart surgery isn’t yet done. I know if reason prevails, Abhinav would not mind sharing the custody.
Pls no more drama here.
Why can’t it be a happy ending?
Akshara, Abhinav & Abhir – it’s a complete family. The character of Abhinav shdnt die. I can’t see Akshara back in the Birla family hell where everyone keep blaming her. What about Aarohi now that she is a changed leaf she shd too get happiness.
All this will happen only if Abhinav’s character isn’t killed. Why do we need a drastic accident of Abhinav, why can’t life be simple?
@Anu for sure they’re going to kill his character. In fact, this track wouldn’t be on if they had been quick enough to find another actor to play Neil, instead of ending NeiRohi and starting this.
-> Abhimanyu from which right is saying Akshara tried to take revenge? And that she tried to take Abhir away from him? The moment she found out one twin was alive, she called Abhimanyu but he didn’t answer it. Then Abhinav called, and Abhimanyu disconnected the call. Abhimanyu’s the one who left the call unanswered, himself unknowingly making Abhinav Akshara’s husband, and Abhir’s father. And now that Abhimanyu knows, he will want to stay with Abhir. Depending on DKP’s mood, Abhimanyu and Akshara might even go to court for custody. Like they did for Kairav, after the Mihir track in 2nd gen. Eventually they’ll probably show Abhimanyu’s lawyer saying not nice things about Akshara, and Abhimanyu telling the lawyer to stop. Like Kartik did. And if custody goes to Akshara, Abhimanyu will make a deal saying he can’t live without his Junior, his Abhir. Saying leave Abhinav and come back to Birla house. If that happens, I hope Akshara doesn’t go back. And even if she does, she goes to Goenka Villa with Abhinav and Abhir, not Birla House. Other than that, happy that Aarohi is changing. She does care about her happiness who she is with, but before it used to be for selfish reasons, now it’s her daughter.<-
If any of my points have upset anyone, then I am sorry.
@Anu.
I agree.
The pairings should go forward as is, without sidelining anybody. Abhimanyu is going through a lot where he hasn’t been aware of his son. I felt his grief and understand he is suffering more than he currently lets out. He has to find joy where he can with Ruhi with his mother on his job with Aarohi and so on. Pursuing Abhir relentlessly is likely to prove destructive as a lot of people will be in pain. So a measured solution looks good where he will have semblance of access and rights while the story continues in stable condition.
@Anu
Hii I think dey will not kill abhinav becoz he also lead now and akshara now with abhinav and she will stick to abhinav only becoz after temple confrontation akshu now she is not feeling love or nothing with abhimanyu I guess she is naturally completely happy with abhinav what all u say?did akshu in love with abhimanyu or abhinav?
@Vijayalakshmi I agree with u, Akshara denied Abhimanyu’s love, and then she and Abhinav stopped calling each other ‘Ji’. Just to show yrkkh and AbhiRa fans, they might end Abhinav and show AbhiRa reconciliation. And yes, Akshara is more happy with Abhinav than she used to be with Abhimanyu. Abhimanyu only blames Akshara, like, Anisha died, Kairav gets the blame for murder, but Akshara gets the blame for saving him, Neil and one of her twins die, Akshara is blamed, and has to hear from Abhimanyu, ‘Sirat Maa ko tum ne hi mara tha, Aarohi sahi keh rahi thi,’ something like that. But with Abhinav, she gets full support, no blames.
@Vijayalakhsmi; @Mishika97.
I believe that Akshara loves Abhinav now she wasn’t aware of that until she came to Udaipur after the six years. Then she sees him as a true husband now. Abhimanyu isn’t a bad choice but the relationship he had with Akshara was overshadowed by so many people and events that it failed completely beyond repair. Akshara has moved on with Abhinav who is the bedrock of support in her world.
I just feel bad for Abhir… this truth will wreck him… Ruhi too…. Now these 2 idiots will war with each other instead of getting Abhir well. I saw some articles saying Abhinav will go against Akshara and work with Abhimanyu to get Abhir treated… Maybe Abhimanyu and Abhinav should just raise both kids together cause these sisters have issues… it can be like 2 and a half men but they also have Ruhi… Abhimanyu and Abhinav’s bromance is better than any romance
Why people r so feminist,as if mahan ak did not commit any mistakes.but always forgave her.she never ever loved him she always used him ,she always choose her family over him .she was ready to chose arohi at her mehndi n ditch abhi.there is no trolling of female like her
Akshara is heaping all the blame on Abhimanyu. She has forgotten all the foolishness she did.
In my congregation, if someone drives a vehicle and have accident and in the process, someone or people list their lives, the driver will be punished. Their must be consequences. Why did she rush to go and face criminals. What did she think, that the goons will say, ah, madam Akshara has come, let’s go in peace. Or they will throw away their arms and run away. She acted foolish and in the process lost two lives. Their must be consequences. The mistake she made, brought a heavy punishment on Abhi, that made him to do his own mistake of divorcing Akshara and cutting contact with her.
The mistake continuous when she hid a child from the father for 6 years.
She kept on putting up Abhi’s fault and he didn’t argue. I want Abhi to put out all her faults before her let’s see whether she will agree.
Now Akshara thought that being a mother gives you the right to dash your child as a gift to whomever man you want, she will soon realize that she’s totally wrong.
Even without knowing Abhir is his child, Abhi has formed an true pure and loving friendship with him. Now that he knows that my junior is my blood, he will never leave him. But before anything get him treated. Let him be well. Then tell him his doc man is his father
Is Akshara herself able to recognize that her choices have consequences? she has mental peace because she thinks she wanted to do this for the good. The day Akshara admits his mistakes and expresses his regrets regarding Niel just like Abhimanyu admitted his mistakes I will look at Akshara differently. Akshara until now has not looked at her own mistakes and puts the blame only on Abhimanyu because he did an injustice to her, and the injustice she did to Abhimanyu she forgot, I will stop talking about it but my opinion will not change. Abhimanyu lost his brother because of Akshara’s choices and he also lost part of his son’s life because of Akshara’s choices because she thought in a personal way and never considered Abhimanyu’s pain.
The episode was so emotional…. akshu nailed …. I donno how the further story will be as abhinv is a very good guy wish nothing wrong happens with him… I lik akshu and ahbimanyu together ❤️ 😌 💕 😍
Today, the file stayed with Akshu. Akshu 1-Abhi 0. Soon the file will be with Abhi as he will do the surgery. Akshu 1-Abhi 1. As usual, no one asked Akshu why she is considering US. Obviously Akshu will not mention Aru name but it doesnt hurt to try. Maybe Aru will finally confess she gave that idea to Sharma family. Anyways, the same kid that Abhi wanted to abort is now all grown up and Abhi is all chanting “i am the father”. Ofcourse he is the bio father. There is a difference. He should ask Abhir who is his father. The same kid Abhi accused Akshu of killing is all safe and sound and Abhi cant help but wish to be his father. Well, if he dont start acting like one, the ship will sail leaving him chanting “i am the father”.
As @Ade said, “Abhi knew the nature of the person he is going to marry”. He thought he could cage this nature of “always wanting to help people” and get away with it? No way. He knew what he went through to free Akshu from the cage her sister put her but he went and put her right into a cage of his own making through promises eg. “Promise me you will not interfere in my family matters” and silencing her in the name of “loving her and so dont want her to be stressed” e.g. i told you i will deal with Aru fake preggy situation. Like Manjiri said during parth matter, “husband and wife issue becomes family issue if a family member sees or hears the issue”. If we go by this logic, Manjiri and harsh issue was world news. Why no one interefered and waited for Akshu to interfere and criticize her for it is beyond me. But at the end of the day, is Manjiri not gratefull for it? Those small girls that were rescued must be grateful for it too. Abhi can now perform his sons surgery because of Akshu one year ordeal. Its true Akshu and Neil did a mistake of not waiting for police but when Neil was beaten up and Akshu went to save him, Neil said, “save the girls first”. This made Neil a hero as at this time, he received his fatal hit on the head. But now this heroic action, was reduced to a meaningless mistake. Neil had the option of running away when things got out of hand but he chose to stick around for those kids.
What bothers me is that, Neil loved this side of Akshu and applauded her for it. So why was this same nature that Neil always commended, be used to blame Akshara.
And regarding Abhi rights as a father, we all know Akshu is fighting a loosing battle. She is trying to protect Nav rights as a father. But she should ask Nav and Abhi if they want to share rights of being Abhirs father. Abhi wanted a filtered Akshu but that needed time, effort .etc. Abhi gave effort but was not ready to give time????
Some people have never needed someone to desperately save them. But those that do need help, wish to get Akshu but by then Abhi would have filtered her already and so these people will die crying for help. The least Abhi could do is pray to Mahadev to keep Ashu and Neil and Manjiri safe always. Afterall, he had faith in him right?
So called Akshara followers don’t find Akshara wrong all her stupid decisions are right for them .
No one understands abhi , his pain and pov . Except Abhinav . As he understands abhi and abhi respects Abhinav . I respect Abhinav as he is so great to bear trashara for many years and beared her . Abhi has anger issues and sometimes I feel Manjiri is the cause of people thinking abhi bad . Yes somewhere even I hate her . Abhi behaviour is mainly because of her and her marriage problems revealed in front of abhi . Seeing his father behaviour with mother , abhi lost faith in marriages. He himself once said he can’t deal with those problems. Yes abhi loved trashara due to her voice which made him calm down and acted like medicine to his pain . Abhi is kind and good. Trashara and her mahanta broke him . She broke him and left him in pain . She is a bad omen to first so called Goenka family and she is not responsible for Sasti sirat death as Sasti sirat didn’t know how to walk so she feel down to her death . Sasti sirat is also reason for trashara to be like that . Trashara never understood Abhi and abhi also couldn’t . As family problems and her stupid behaviour of running away . All blame abhi and name him as selfish, self centred and many more . Due to her stupid behaviour Neil died and she lost one of her babies . She is responsible for it as she doesn’t use brain . In weak moment or when we lose someone dearly people act like that . I saw many times in my life . Even I did and I apologised too . Ruhi is so important to abhi as she is his Neil last memory. She loves her poppy very much . Trashara is wrong and no one can hide truth like that . Separating father and son is wrong. I don’t know what more drama and I know stupid people will not understand abhi and write stupid comments blaming him . His actions are due to his pain . I saw a lot of change in abhi . I love abhi , Ruhi , Abhir , Abhinav and aarohi . I hate trashara, stupid kairav and Manjiri . I love Harshad , pranali , Hera , shreyansh and Karishma Sawant . I hate characters but not actors who play them.
The main difference I noticed in abhimanyu is he has this fantacy of being a good father due to his not so good relationship with his own father. He wants to fulfill that fantasy 🤦🏻♀️ all throughout his dialogues he kept saying that only yes he has right to know his kid but reasoning seems so 😔 he needs to put his childs welfare happiness first. And to be honest destiny has not been unkind to him for taking away his children he was also given a chance to be father to a lovely daughter. Both men have played a role of father to not their own kid but the heart to heart connection that abhinav has with abhir is missing with abhimanyu. and now it’s very important for abhimanyu to balance that for his zidd hopefully he will not lose the precious gift he was given his roohi.
The pain Akshara and Abhimanyu carry inside themselves was brilliantly expressed. Abhinav saved Abhir’s life when Akshara birth him. That is why Akshara decided to gift Abhinav the status of being Abhir’s Dad. Now Abhimanyu is about to perform life saving surgery to save Abhir’s life. That makes both men equal under Akshara’s logic. She, though, is still determined to keep Abhimanyu apart from Abhir. Why, because he was an unsupportive husband? Was she a supportive enough wife? The trauma of miscarriage happened to both of them, though, she suffered the physical effects too. But Neil’s death, Akshara needs to appreciate the laws of cause and effect and take responsibility for her actions that put Neil in the line of danger. Also, Abhimanyu lost a beloved younger brother, she only lost a brother in law. She is much like Manjiri in that she only sees her pain and not that of others. Both Abhimanyu and Abhinav have now told Akshara her decisions should not be directed by her view that Abhimanyu failed her as a husband but by what is best for the child. There is no reason why Abhir needs to chose between Abhinav or Abhimanyu if the adults themselves join hands to safeguard a happy life for him from now on. We have seen the men overcoming their differences over the love for Akshara to build a friendship of respect. Can Akshara and Abhimanyu become friends?
How can Akshara forget the part.
When Abhi called, Abhinav answered and and when Abhinav said “don’t you want to her if the mother of your child” and Abhi said “yes, even then I don’t want to meet her”
Am l the only one who isnt looking forward to Manjiri Birla’s outburst when the truth comes out.
I wonder what will Abhi reaction be when he finds out Arohi also knew the truth.
Akshara Legally doesnt have the right to give fatherly rights to abinav out of gartitude just because he stood by them when they are in need. He can be a father to abir and still abimanyu is hes real dad and also play a role in his life. Both father and mother has equal rights and no matter how bad among them is he is still the father or mother. In this akshara intentionally conceal and hide the truth from everyone just because of her personal issues. Abhi doesnt have issues with abhir he has issues with akshara as they were divorced and when you intentional aid and abet the truth of which thats what abhinav and akshara did to abhi they can loose the custody to abhimanyu.
Now its about abhirs health of which abhimanyu knows as a dr its risky for them to make him travel and gave his opinion of which akshara said only a mother and father has the right to decide so now abhimanyu as the father of abhir his opinion matters.
Abinav sees himself as abhirs dad but that doesnt stop him from taking abhimanyus place he knows his limit and is ready to give anything for abhirs well being.
Now confrontation is between two mothers manjiri and akshara who only thinks of her child and nothing else. If manjiri can decide who abhi can spend his life with as a patner then why cant akshu decide who abhir will spend his life with as his father. This track is to make manjiri feel how bad she thinks as a mother as she only thought of her self and nothing else. When you are doing something you dont see it until when someone does it to you thats when you will feel it.
Abir is her biological grandchild while roohi is not. She raised neil and loved him like her son but she treats them seperately their affection is different and she gives priority to abhimanyu than neil.
If akshara babies were alive manjiri will not oust her from the house. As a mother she also used abhimanyu against his dad as she has never tried to clear the differences between the two. She silently used her son against his dad as mother abhi listens to only her and no one else. She wanted abhimanyu to live with his dad but not to have bond with him but only her.
The only differennce with manjiri and akshara is that manjiri lived with abhis dad but snatched his fatherly rights from harshand while akshara completely shatched the fatherly rights and gave it so someone
I wonder how Akshara is expected to know about Manjiri is condition 6years ago when she had left Udaipur and the only person she tried to get in touch with shut her down. Is she a mind reader or a psychic!!!
Abhimanyu toxic Birla’s pain is not bigger than Akshara is pain because he wasn’t the one abandoned after going through a miscarriage and he wasn’t the one who was accused for Neil’s death, he wasn’t the one who no one listened to for their side of the story or got divorced in a heartbeat and told to leave her home in the same breathe. He didn’t lose his entire family or get blamed for a misfortune.
I will not blame Akshara for Neil is death because Neil was a willing participant. He wasn’t coerced and if he was alive, he would defend Akshara against all those foolish accusations. An unfortunate incident happened when two people were trying to do good. No one thinks rationally when they are in the heat of the moment dealing with trouble. Such is life.
So for all intents and purposes, Abhimanyu let his anger get the best of him and used Akshara as a punching bag for his pain. In the process, he said things he cannot take back and acted in a way that gave Akshara the green light to move on and make a better life for her child under the circumstances.
No woman wants to be alone while pregnant even when it is a safe pregnancy. Akshara got a support system in a stranger who turned out to be better than all the people she had known all her life. Making him responsible for Abhir as a father isn’t a crime because Abhinav fulfilled that responsibility and is willing to lay down his life for Abhir. If Abhinav wasn’t willing to share Abhir is fatherhood with Abhimanyu then I would wonder if Akshara made the right choice for Abhir.
Paternity doesn’t not equate to fatherhood otherwise even sperm donors can have a claim over the sperms they donated that resulted into children.
Aarohi is a threat to Abhir’s well being. How is Abhimanyu going to manage her and Ruhi especially if she becomes his wife.
Manjiri is another threat to Abhir is peace of mind as she has turned out to be a narcissist and quite vengeful. If she can scold a child just because she doesn’t like the mother, then what kind of person is that who visits the “sins” of the mother on a child. I now wonder how she managed to love the child of her husband is mistress.
Abhimanyu failed to balance relationships 6years ago and even now, the scale is still tipped in his mother is favor. Will he allow to co-parent with Akshara or try to use the law and his money to usurp her rights!!!
Whatever happens as all that will happen will be according to what the makers want, they should not advance the idea of a happily ever after for Abhira. That ship sailed and was crushed at the temple. Even Abhirohi is not an option. Abhimanyu is the hottest bachelor in Udaipur so he cannot lack a mate except in the ITV world.
@Rach
And I was wondering, if after the last 6 years of searching Abhinav would be the one to bring the remnants of Akshu and Abher back to Abhi, and announce she had died in bed while giving birth, what will happen????
@Flower, by then Manjiri n Aarohi will said ” oh an life for an life” and it’s her karma! Abhimanyu will shout why my child??? And be sad for a moment n move on 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Exactly….if the coin was flipped and Abhinav informed Abhimanyu of the unfortunate death of his ex-wife while giving birth to their remaining child, what would Abhimanyu do. Tbh, Abhinav has been quite generous to Abhimanyu especially since he too knows he refused to listen to him when he called about Abhir and Akshara. Another man would not have bothered to feel bad for that kind of person. The man even unknowingly revealed the truth to him. Fans abusing his character make me 🤔
@Flower.
😂.
I’m laughing so hard that I think that I will cry. Well it’s just that some of us have similar attributes to the characters and yet we are unable to see that. Akshara makes mistakes and she often doesn’t own up to them. Okay accepted. But why does she own up to her mistakes with Abhinav and try to pacify him. What changed? It’s because she feels at ease in this relationship. Abhimanyu conveniently forgot about Akshara for years then when he saw her again in Udaipur he started having vivid dreams about her. Now the same is happening with Abhir. He couldn’t know that there was a storm on the day of Abhir’s birth but he stands ready to claim parental rights. What if they both died then he will wallow in what? Self pity or so. He was wrong in how he set up the events after the divorce. Then he heard that Akshara married and started drinking. But enough of that. I think an amicable solution can help him here while he is better served looking elsewhere for his happiness instead of fighting with his ex over rights he carelessly vacated. That statement still rings in my ears. He didn’t know what it meant but now he knows why Akshara did what she did.
@Rach.
So true. I’m inclined to agree with your points. I see that Akshara was helping some disadvantaged children and the situation went awry. Then the pre-leap and the divorce and all that. Abhimanyu is living in a world of his own making. I don’t see how blaming Akshara for not fighting against the divorce or for not getting news of the surviving baby across to Abhimanyu changes his gigantic wrongdoing. At the beginning of the third generation, Abhimanyu is shown to not have belief in marriage so he’s misogamist. He had divorce papers in his drawers and he loves Akshara with all his heart. But wait until Abhinav comes and shows Akshara what love truly is. Instead of divorce papers in the drawers she finds love letters in a jewelry box. Why won’t she choose that? It wasn’t even about the money. It was about the natures of the two men in her life.Even now Abhimanyu is changing for the better and I admire the improvements. However she isn’t perfect but then she chose right for a new life. I can’t begrudge her for that.
Abhimanyu said “Why is a father is punished for the wrong done by a husband”, he said “No one can snatch father’s rights from him just because he is a failed husband”, then dude, Why did you hate your father all your life, Harsh was a pathetic husband but he loved his son and always wished best for him, so why did he receive hate from his son and is judged on how he is as a father based on how he was as a husband, Abhimanyu didn’t even let him tie pagdi during his marriage and snatched his “right” as according to him Manjiri has more right as she was the one who did everything for him, same goes to Abhir then, Akshara and Abhinav will always have more right than Abhimanyu. This guy was always full of double standards. He always behaved according to his way not considering about anyone other than his mother, at first acted as super hero trying to save his love from her sister’s “abuse” by constantly interfering between the sisters, like who the hell is he to even behave like a control freak between sisters, it’s the job of family to mend the sister’s relation but here I blame Goenkas too, they gave him too much leverage that he started dancing on every person’s head of both families. I can never forget the way he insulted Aarohi, Kairav and Goenkas, but still Goenkas worship him, what a trash family!
Akshara has all rights to decide about her son, I understand her state of mind and emotions for making Abhinav as father and I even acknowledge and accept the fact that Abhinav is Abhir’s father in all sense but still Akshara will be held accountable legally.
1. She changed father’s name on Birth certificate. She shouldn’t have done that. She has no rights to meddle with legal documents, she should have kept the name as Abhimanyu only, it makes no harm or doesn’t lessen Abhinav’s rights.
2. She passed on the father rights to someone else legally and the biological father has no clue that his son is alive, she can’t state the excuse of him not lifting call, the next question will be “Why didn’t you contact your family?”, or “Why is your family and relatives are kept in dark?”, her case will be very weak.
3. She should have first fought for the custody of her child, charge Abhimanyu for causing her emotional damage right after miscarriage, gain sole custody of her child, then marry Abhinav or whomever she wishes to and gave him legal rights, in this case her side of case would be strong but now Abhimanyu’s case will be strong for sure, he has many valid and strong points like hiding a child, passing on legal rights to someone else without his consent, meddling with kid’s age and Birth certificate, etc. I still can’t believe that she’s studying law but made these many blunders making her side of case weak.
@Mounika, agree with you, I wonder why she studies law but has no real knowledge of the fact that she is in bad possession legally speaking. Other than that, maybe the scriptwriters don’t want to use real tangible law to support Abhimanyu’s case, maybe they’ll make the law follow their script, because Akshara no longer has any chance of winning the case if brought to justice, she is seen as a person who violated Abhimanyu’s rights and harmed him. She also doesn’t try to use a friendlier strategy to avoid legal repercussions. I too understand Abhimanyu’s situation and sincerely respect that he does not try to justify his bad deeds, but with all that he and his family have done to the Goenka children, I cannot forget like That. I understand everyone’s opinion but the Birla family is not an environment where you have to raise a child the same for the Goenka family
Maybe in India it is a crime to make someone else the father of your child but in my neck of the woods, it is not legally or otherwise. However, the man can fight for paternity and custody. Paternity can be granted on proof of DNA but custody will require a lot more than just proof of paternity. The potential father has to prove the mother is not fit to raise the child and it is in the child is best interest to stay with him. And if the child is below the age of 6, the mother has automatic custody until you can prove they don’t deserve to have it. Given that it is ITV where the laws are flaunted and the makers show whatever they want to show, your arguments can hold but in reality, that is all hogwash until you prove the mother is unfit or incapable of raising their child. The best one can do is seek for joint custody with the child staying mostly with the parent they have grown up with until they get used to the other parent.
@Rachel it’s not that simple, you can easily take custody of her child away from a mother unfortunately. In the case of Akshara this is called a substitution of rights the transfer of your rights and duties vis-à-vis your children, aims to help you and / or support you in their instruction and education , but this case is only valid if the biological father has abandoned his parental rights and this is proven. Akshara has substituted Abhimanyu’s rights without his knowledge and if it is proven that Abhimanyu had the means and the desire to take care of his son, the law will be intransigent, and the case will turn into a custody proceeding, and in this point Akshara has already legally violated several rights of Abhimanyu as a father, he will try to prove each that they have an established financial situation for the well-being of the child and that he will be able to enjoy a better quality of life . they are universal laws valid in Asia in Europe and in several other countries. The international constitution of rights changed in 2020 and promotes co-parenting so that it allows parents to maintain strong and regular links with their child so that he receives care, education, instruction and moral assistance. of each of them. But Akshara has committed judicial fraud in substitution to Abhimanyu her rights, she has very little chance of winning joint custody.
A child’s mental’s wellbeing will also be taken into consideration not only physical!
@Mounika.
So insightful. I have learnt a few things here with the granular analysis of the Akshara’s divorce story. As it is. Akshara will only win the moral victories. But this concerns Abhimanyu and he doesn’t fight these kinds of battles with kind consideration. He will use every loophole that he can find in invalidate the prior arrangement. This is where Akshara can get to settle the matter without recourse to a court hearing, where everything will be up for grabs.
@Ariya
Abhi refused when Abhinav called to inform Abhi when she gave birth to Abher, and Abhi replied it had nothing to do with Akshu and her baby. Is it still considered a legal refusal ?
@Flower yes it is considered legal denial if Abhimanyu knew about Abhir’s existence or if audio evidence exists then legal process could be very complicated for Abhimanyu.
@Flower
I’m sorry I think you have some misconception, none called Abhimanyu to inform about Abhir after his birth, did you forget Akshara was in coma and Abhinav was busy taking care of weak infant. Akshara called Abhimanyu only once, but at that time Manjiri was admitted in hospital and he refused to listen, the second time he called back Akshara and Abhinav lifted the call, when he tried to tell Abhimanyu about Akshara’s pregnancy, he yelled at Abhinav, refused to listen and cut the call.
@Francis
Yes, morally Akshara will not be questioned as what she did is correct and the best for her kid, but she’ll for sure face legal consequences because she messed up a big time by doing forgery of Birth certificate and meddling with legal documents, even in Gen 2 Naira had to face legal consequences for hiding Kairav, she was questioned in court but at the end was granted custody as Kartik took back the case at the end realizing Kairav can’t live without his mother. But here, it will clearly be a case of parental fraud, as we all know court doesn’t see emotions but sees evidences, all these years Akshara should have made her side of case strong to avoid any complications if legal battle arrives but she did nothing.
I don’t think Akshara forged the BC she was divorced and Abbinav is ready to be Abhir’s father why can’t she put Abhinav name as Abhir’s father?? There are cases where step father are name as his wife’s child father!
Yes you dun complicate matter by putting the biological father’s name on the child BC when the mother is remarried!
@Sivk
Birth Certificate is something where biological parents name should be there, not someone else name. If the bio dad is dead also, his name only will be present on Birth certificate. If the mother remarries, then the step father name will be there in other study certificates but in Birth certificate biological parents only should be mentioned. In this case, the bio dad is unaware of his son’s existence. It will obviously come under forgery of Birth certificate only.
@Rach
I don’t know in which country you live in but in India what Akshara did with Birth certificate will be considered as fraud, Birth certificate is also a kind of legal document and forging with legal document is a crime in India. Generally in India too, the preference would be given to mother considering that Abhir is just 5 years old but with this forgery thing will make a negative impact on Akshara’s image as mother. If she didn’t do that obviously Abhimanyu would have got just visitation rights and legal rights would be with Akshara only but now Abhimanyu’s side is strong comparatively.
@Ariya
If there is no audio recording, Akshu requests to retrieve the call log, will the time details still be considered evidence Akshu made every effort to inform Abhi about Abher? For Akshu’s sake, Abhinav would not think to return to Udaipur. Furthermore, after asking (but rather expelling) Akshu out of Birla’s house, for the past 6 years, he has not searched for her once, even though Abhi knows that she is both physically and emotionally traumatized. spirit, where was Akshu . So does it apply to Abhi’s moral code?
@Ariya
Yes, she’s really in bad position legally but as we all know this is ITV and here FLs are never shown as wrong, so I’m sure even if custody track starts, Akshara will win it at the end, maybe Abhimanyu only will take back the case seeing Abhir happy with Akshara and Abhinav just like how Kartik took back the case seeing Kairav happy with Naira. But, if we see from real world POV, Akshara and Abhinav both wouldn’t be spared in courts, they may even loose Abhir forever as we know courts will never prefer people with criminal history for custody, the court may even put Abhir in childcare center if they feel both Abhimanyu and Akshara are unfit to raise the child.
No kid should be raised in Birla and Goenka families, I believe the main reason for Akshara and Aarohi’s sufferings are Goenkas only partially, they failed to make a balance between children when the became orphans at 8. Abhir was anyways raised away from these families, Aarohi ahould analyze from her own experience and go far away with her daughter before it’s too late. She can then marry a person who loves her and also Ruhi so that even she stays content in life, infact she should have never let Abhimanyu become an inseparable part of Ruhi’s life. She should have let Abhimanyu be an uncle only. At this point, I don’t think Ruhi will accept any other man as her father figure as she made her poppy her whole world.
@Mounika true Arohi let Abhimanyu had too much sway in Ruhi’s life and your view of the real and exact situation, you are also right Goenka’s interference caused both girls’ problems but their adult character and a choice of life, growing up you have to get a clear idea between good and evil, you naturally begin to have your own opinion, their character reflects their personality
How is it Abhimanyu n Akshara has criminal history???
@Mounika
I watched ep Akshu trying to call Abhi, and it was Abhinav who phoned Abhi informing about Akshu and her baby telling Abhi, Abhi got Abhinav’s call. You can search again
@Flower not really, according to the law to explain that you resorted to several kinds of less to warn a father they will ask for proof and prove that Abhimanyu was in full knowledge of his paternity but that he deliberately ignored his duties. After a divorce recognized by the court of justice it is considered that you are no longer responsible for each other, so if you have something to say to the other the person must of course contact him either because he no longer has any responsibility towards the person. But one thing is strange Abhimanyu at that time had not submitted the divorce papers to the judge so legally he was still responsible for Akshara’s welfare she could have used that argument because Abhimanyu failed in his moral duties in as a husband. But now Akshara has committed several criminal and judicial offences, she risks a criminal record, so she is in a very bad position, because the prosecution will never entrust a child to parents who have criminal backgrounds if they have the choice. And if during the trial Abhimanyu and also deemed unfit for custody of Abhir, the little one will be temporarily placed in foster homes. If Akshara hadn’t committed so much legal offense they both could have enjoyed joint custody because Abhir’s psychological state will be taken into consideration because he recognized another person as his parents and even though Abhinav Had no legal rights over Abhir Akshara would never have lost full custody of Abhir as she is legally married and provided a stable home for Abhir. But now legally Akshara’s case is not favorable. an amicable confrontation and preferable they can also consult lawyers without having recourse directly to the court if the situation is settled peacefully.
@Flower
I think that’s what I mentioned in my comment, you said that Abhinav called Abhimanyu after Abhir’s birth but that’s not true, both Abhinav and Akshara called him when they got to know one baby is alive but Abhimanyu refused to listen, no one called Abhimanyu after Abhir’s birth. Just wanted to mention that.
@Ariya
Thank you for giving me a lot of useful legal information
If Abher only calls Abhinav his father, but without his father’s name on Abher’s birth certificate, the problem is extenuating in Akshu’s case?
@Flower yes
@Ariya
I reiterate that it could be different in India but in my country, all the reasons you guys are advancing will never win Abhimanyu sole custody of his son. It is the reality not movies or ITV. Our law clearly states that for a child below 7years, the mother has custody but the father can get visiting rights and has to pay maintenance for the child except if the mother is incapable of taking care of the child then he can get custody of the child. A child of 12yrs and above, can be asked to weigh in on where he wants to stay…the child can even choose another relative and if court thinks it is for their wellbeing, they can grant it. Most men are raising children who are not their biological children and only get to find out at divorce or when the woman dies and the relatives inform the guy. Another man raising another man’s child knowingly or unknowing ain’t novel. So let’s not dwell on it like it is so out of this world and the woman deserves to be stoned. The question should be if she made a good or bad choice of a father for her child. I rest my case.
@Rachel I am not Indian I am European and I work in the legal social field, the case of Akshara is not an isolated case nowadays we grant almost the same parental rights to a woman as to a man. I’ve worked in several cases like this, most of the time the parents end up getting joint custody. Now men have the same rights in some countries in Europe and Asia to have a say in abortion, if a man doesn’t want to have a baby, a procedure and throw and debate in court and pursues, even if it is about the body of the woman (I am a woman and I find that completely unfair). In Europe The offense of forgery, such as the use of forgery, is punishable by 3 years in prison and a fine of €45,000 Akshara usurped Abhimanyu’s rights, there is a whole trial to prove his rights named another man as father and in Akshara’s case she was not within her rights. A man may be unaware of being a father for years, but if one day he discovers it and he has no criminal record, he is entitled to claim rights over his offspring and the custody of his child in a biased way. And finally, in some cases even teenagers in many situations are not allowed to choose which parents they can stay with, teenagers often seek to be placed with the parent where they will have more freedom and who will not be able to control them. , but the law only looks at the well-being of the teenager even if he does not really like the parent with whom he is going to be placed. Many men actually raise children who are not their own and find out later, when they divorce and custody proceedings are launched, even if it is unfair the biological parent always has more rights and in some cases the adoptive father cannot even benefit from visitation rights because the mother has decided to refuse him the rights that she had granted him.
I still feel akshu should have left abhi after the divorce, gone back to goenkas, filed a case on abhi and birlas saying they harassed her, taken complate rights over abhir, used goenkas money and studied some music, become a professional singer.
I know she was mentally weak to fight, and it would have ruined her peace of mind. But at that time, she surely was the victim and everything would have been in her favour. Courts would have deemed birlas and abhi violent not good enough to raise a child. Now it is going to be a more difficult legal battle.
@Gunjan
Do you think Akshu will do that to Abhi, Manjari? My answer is NEVER. Arohi has harmed Akshu many times, even she almost lost her life, will she reveal the truth? The answer is NO. Arohi is the one who caused Manjari’s accident, will she reveal the truth? The answer is NO. human nature Aksshu won’t do these things to the people she loves. And this is also Akshu’s weakness
Well that’s the issue with her. Now she’s giving lecture to abhi. But this lecture would have been way more effective 6 years back, or even after the birth of abhir. Now she will be dragged to court by her richer and supposedly wronged-by-her ex husband. Her chances of winning the case are lesser as compared to her chances of winning if this case had happened 6 years ago. Here feelings won’t be taken into consideration, only facts. And the fact is:
– abhi divorced akshu
– akshu was pregnant
– akshu did not inform abhi of the pregnancy
– hence there was no division of rights on the baby
Had akshu and abhi not married or married and abhi asked her to abort the baby, then he can’t have absolutely any rights on the baby; if abhi and akshu were just together/ dating/ not serious and akshu got pregnant and abhi had wanted nothing to do with the child, then she has absolutely all rights on abhir. But this case is different.
Unecessarily, she’ll be dragged to court. And abhir too. Added to that, she could have spoken nicely to abhi to put her point across, she was super rude- it was more like she wanted him to shut up so she raised her voice and spoke. He got to know he has a son after 6 years, it’s not the same thing, atleast she could have been little nicer in her approach and can come to a settlement. But she’ll pinch his ego again, and he being a brainlesz person, will do whatever he can this time. And this time the points are on his side because he is financially more capable than akshu-abhinav.
I think there is hope for Abhira, though small, its there. Nav decreased this chance big time but there is a window of hope though doors are closed. And this hope has nothing to do with Nav disappearance or Abhir future wishes.
Would like to see Abhimanyu in negative character, he would nail it 😂
I think both abhimanyu and akshara will lose custody case in court and abhinav will be granted custody as happened in yeh hai mohabbatein how that Roohi chose her ishima🤣🤣🤣 i really don’t think akshara was responsible for Neil’s death as Neil’s not a small child, he was adult well capable of thinking of consequences and she asked him if he received the call for help what he will do she will do as he says and he decided to go to concert location so fault lies with Both of them and they both were in equal danger and could have died as akshara said if she had died birlas would never have broken ties with neil like they did with her. Abhimanyu doesn’t seem to be in hurry to inform family the truth but he sure is planning and playing with akshara’s fear. And I hated his cocky attitude in precap like your kid is sick and you are acting like this 🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️ i might be wrong will see tomorrow but I don’t feel much sympathy for him as he seems back to his old avatar and how his love is owning a person using whatever means like he did for akshara.
@Ashkey there is a possibility, because Abhinav has a right recognized by law the right of a third party he can apply to court to get custody of Abhir even if he has no legal rights, because the child recognized him like a parent and he played a role in his upbringing. This demand is not necessarily linked to unhealthy parental behavior. The third party (Abhinav) who wishes to obtain custody of the child must demonstrate to the judge that it is the interest of the child which makes this decision necessary. and with Akshara and Abhimanyu’s uncooperative behavior its would be possible. But if Abhinav is finally found to be an accomplice in Akshara’s business considered illegal, his right will be taken away from him.
Abhi he accepted his mistakes but he also said he can’t give up on abhir eventhough both abhi and akshu both wrong today Harshad acting mind blowing abhi accepted hid mistakes akshu will not forgive him akshu can forgive anyone even manjiri aarohi but she can’t forgive abhi super did abhi forgot ruhi already don’t make ruhi feel insecure although goenka and birla pamper ruhi so much they make ruhi aware of her father neil but in abhir case no one know truth except goenka siblings akshu abhinav abhi Noone can predict how goenka react
Guys, I have read all your comments, please answer my query. Akshara Abhimanyu fell in love and got married after many dramas. Both made a promise to trust and respect each other and to keep trusting no matter how many castes come in between, but Abhimanyu broke it all the times. However, Akshara came to Abhimanyu forgiving everything to take all the easy and live with Abhimanyu. Even though the pregnancy carries a risk to her life, (Manjari wants his son has a kid so that his veins and his name should go on, and Abhimanyu’s too wants his child and he wants to be best papa. On heard the words from his mother and Abhimanyu Akshara prepared for it and took the decision). On regular interval medical checkups, she carries the pregnancy under doctor’s observation everyone knows this. There is no denying that Akshara is not wrong in the case of Neil, but how can a lady be kicked out of the house in such medical conditions, they don’t do it if they are human being, but they are Birlas self-centered personnel. Where did Abhimanyu give respect to Akshara? Abhimanyu’s entire life was following his mother, It’s not that he should not love, respect his mom, A mother’s position is a mother’s, a wife’s position is a wife’s, these two should be balanced, which one is not there in Abhimanyu. How he left with his promise given to his wife, Why he didn’t trust in such conditions. Is this the respect given to the wife, where is the trust and respect of his wife?. If Akshara dies in the nail place, what will Birlas do with the Neil??????. What will happen??? Nothing because they are Birlas.